BACK UP BLOG (no longer updating)

This blog was a backup for American Indian Adoptees blog
USE THE SEARCH BAR or SEARCH TOPICS at bottom of this blog

If you need support

Support Info: If you are a Survivor and need emotional support, a national crisis line is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week: Residential School Survivor Support Line: 1-866-925-4419. Additional Health Support Information: Emotional, cultural, and professional support services are also available to Survivors and their families through the Indian Residential Schools Resolution Health Support Program. Services can be accessed on an individual, family, or group basis.” These & regional support phone numbers are found at https://nctr.ca/contact/survivors/ . MY EMAIL: tracelara@pm.me

Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Veronica Krupnick. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Veronica Krupnick. Show all posts

Friday, July 26, 2024

Fearless: Veronica Krupnick is a voice for change in New Mexico

Alexandra Wittenberg | Navajo-Hopi Observer



SANTA FE, NM. — On her great-grandmother’s 91st birthday celebration at Jemez Pueblo in April, Veronica Krupnick gave her the news she would be on the ballot for the New Mexico State Senate.

With tear-filled eyes, she looked at Krupnick, hugged her, and then sat her down to eat.

“She went from seeing Native Americans in New Mexico not be able to vote until 1948 to now seeing her great granddaughter on a ballot,” Krupnick said.

Krupnick is 28; her great-grandmother was 24 when Native Americans got the right to vote in the state.

 “If you’re bold enough to dream big and fight for the changes you want to see, you can see that kind of radical turnaround in one person’s lifetime,” Krupnick said. “But you have to feel the fear and do it anyway.”

Though Krupnick lost the Democratic primary election for District 24 in Santa Fe to Linda Trujillo in June, her work in the New Mexico House of Representatives and as a fierce advocate for child welfare has anything but slowed.

“(Running) taught me a lot,” Krupnick said. “This is something that I want to do, maybe not in the near future but down the road. It definitely takes a lot out of you.”

Krupnick said although an estimated 45% of New Mexicans are under the age of 35, they don’t really have representation.

She also thought her expertise in child welfare would fill a much-needed gap in the state, especially with the upcoming retirement of two long-time legislative officials.

“One of the biggest (changes) that could really shift things for child welfare is proactively getting people with experience involved, whether that’s at a local or a state (level),” Krupnick said. “Lived-experience people are going to tell you what works and what doesn’t…I think in child welfare we get really lost in the numbers and the statistics and we forget that there’s people behind them.”

 Krupnick uses her own experience in the foster and adoption systems to try and spark change, and she strives to bring others that have been in the system to use their own voices.

Early life

Krupnick was born in Tuba City, Arizona, to teenage parents. Her biological father is Hopi and she grew up in Moenkopi on the Hopi reservation. Krupnick also has Jemez and Navajo heritage.

“I kind of bounced around to different family members for those first couple of years,” Krupnick said. “My biological parents really struggled with addiction and were involved in the incarceration system and juvenile justice pretty early.”

When she was 4-years-old, Krupnick moved with her mother to Albuquerque to be closer to her mother’s family on the Jemez reservation.

“She was really hoping I think to turn things around … but you know, life doesn’t go according to plan,” Krupnick said.

Krupnick said her mother fell into the drug scene in Albuquerque, and got into legal trouble. By the time Krupnick was 6, her mother was facing charges of child abuse and neglect, and Krupnick was put into the foster care system, going between her mother and a group home at first, until it was determined she would be adopted.

At 7, Krupnick’s younger sister was born to an African American father. Though their mother had family on the Jemez reservation, she was not registered to the tribe. That meant Krupnick had legal kinship placement through her biological father’s Hopi side, but her half-sister had none.

 “That kind of made it complicated,” Krupnick said.

The Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) of 1978 mandates that American Indian children should be adopted into American Indian families.

“Our legal case then became a question of, do we come from ICWA because it does apply to me and separate us, or do you keep us together? That’s why (adoption) took about a year, because we had to get my tribe involved.”

Until she was adopted at 10, Krupnick was placed in seven different foster care families, many non-tribal.

Stakeholders helped the girls’ team navigate through the hoops of the adoption process, and it was ultimately decided that Krupnick and her half-sister — who were very close — should be adopted together. However, a Native home that would take them as a package could not be found, so they were adopted into a white family.

“We were adopted and it opened up a whole new wave of different struggles,” Krupnick said. “Those first 10 years were just a struggle to survive, and then after adoption I feel like it was the first time I had processed any of the stuff that had happened before.”

Krupnick said although her adopted parents had the best intentions, she struggled with the disconnect from her culture and the struggle that many transracial adoptees — and regular adoptees —face.

“A lot of times in adoption cases like mine, once an adoption is closed, everything before that day in the child’s life is cut off,” Krupnick said. “Family, friends, schools, pets, home — all of that — it no longer looks the same.”

Krupnick got involved with the juvenile detention system at 14 for petty crimes like theft.

“I was a really angry teenager who kind of had an ‘I don’t know who’s driving’ period of life, (which) is not something uncommon to see in post adoptees,” Krupnick said. “(I was) living off of impulses and harmful decisions.”

At 16, Krupnick ended up at a residential treatment facility in Utah.

“I felt like for the most part, I was kind of given some space to kind of actually heal myself without the pressure (to also) fit into a new family,” Krupnick said. “I think that was what I really needed and I think I really thrived there.”

Krupnick graduated the program in 10 months and moved to a transitional/independent living program nearby before heading to Fort Lewis College in Durango, Colorado.

“I showed up to college with two suitcases and that’s about it,” Krupnick said.

She paid for the majority of her schooling on her own, working as a student ambassador during the day between her classes, and a pharmacy technician at night. She majored in public health with a minor in psychology.

A taste of advocacy

Early on in her college career, Krupnick became a wellness peer advising counselor through a program called eMPAS.

“We focused on suicide and sexual assault prevention, both areas that I have struggled with,” Krupnick said. “(It) gave me a little taste of lived-experience advocacy, which I really enjoyed.”

Krupnick attributes the program to the start of her advocacy career, which started in 2018 with the Court Appointed Special Advocate (CASA) Program and Tewa Women United. She worked for the Casey Family Programs and won a national Casey Excellence for Children Alumni Award this year for her dedication to youth mentorship.

She still volunteers at CASA, now as the vice president on the board of directors, and volunteers on several other boards and programs while maintaining her full-time job as a Leadership Analyst for the New Mexico House of Representatives Majority Leader Representative Gail Chasey.

“I do a little bit of everything,” Krupnick said. “Everything from answering constituent concerns to serving as a child welfare specialist, vetting legislation, setting up meetings with stakeholders, helping with classifiers and going to community meetings.”

Krupnick said during legislative sessions, where she sits as senate liaison, she averages 16 hour days, but she loves the work and staying busy.

Cultural connection

 

Veronica Krupnick testified for U.S. Secretary of the Interior Deb Haaland’s Supreme Court case, defending the Indian Child Welfare Act, in 2023. (Photo/Veronica Krupnick)

In spring 2023, Krupnick testified nationally during the Haaland vs. Brackeen Supreme Court case, which could have dismantled ICWA, but kept it intact after a 7-2 vote.

“I was using my voice as much as possible; I was speaking at summits, at rallies. I was writing op-ed pieces, all of that good stuff,” Krupnick said. “ICWA definitely became a really big part of my professional life and really I was trying to call the importance of keeping the adopted in Native communities, and in the worst case, if they are adopted outside of them, really working (to make sure) those children have a lifeline back to their culture and their community and those doors are open.”

In 2022, Krupnick played a role in establishing the Indian Family Protection Act (IFPA), New Mexico’s counterpart to the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA).

“It has things which the federal law doesn’t and is inclusive of what they call a cultural contract,” Krupnick said. ‘So that’s what is in the adoption decree … essentially saying if you are going to adopt this child from this tribe, this is the plan to keep this child connected to their culture and their connections.”

Krupnick is now helping to set up IFPA courts around the state, and said the first IFPA court has higher rates of success for adoption and foster youth than ICWA.

“I think (IFPA) gives clarity to the adopted parents and I think it gives the adoptee something to stand on,” Krupnick said. “If you are going to adopt this child you are going to take this cultural identity with them.”

Looking back, Krupnick expressed gratitude for the week-long visits to the Hopi reservation that her adoptive parents arranged. During these visits, she volunteered with the Red Feather program to help build houses. These experiences allowed her to form positive connections with other Hopi families and stay connected to her cultural heritage.

“My roots and my culture have been so foundational and so key to my healing that it always kinds of make me wonder — had those not been so distinctive, would it have been something that could have helped me?” she said.

She is now connected to her Hopi and Jemez family excluding her parents. She now has two other younger siblings on her mother’s side and four on her father’s. The half-sister she was adopted with is now 21, and the two are still as close as can be, roommates and dog moms in Santa Fe.

With the small amount of time Krupnick’s not working or volunteering, she relaxes by binging Netflix ‘junk food’ shows like Dancing with the Stars, The Bachelor and Bridgerton.

But she can’t help watching Law and Order and Criminal Minds, too.

“My brain apparently doesn’t like to turn off,” she laughed.

 

Wednesday, September 13, 2023

A coyote would appear... Veronica Krupnick (Hopi)


There once was a girl who lived in Corrales and loved collecting butterflies. She would capture perhaps 20 or 30 of them at a time, take them inside, then set them free to fly around her bedroom. Another thing she noticed about herself: Whenever she happened to be on the verge of a big life change, a coyote would appear. “Not like one running across the road,” Veronica Krupnick, now 27 years old, recalled, “but like I’d be out on a walk with my family, and a coyote would follow along close behind us.” 

For years, these uncanny animal connections struck her as mysterious and sometimes unsettling. “I didn’t have anyone to teach me about them,” Krupnick said, until she was reintroduced to her Hopi grandparents when she was 19 or 20. It was then that she learned that the coyote and the butterfly are among her clan affiliations. Suddenly, these aspects of her life, along with others, began to make sense.

An enrolled member of the Hopi tribe, Krupnick’s lineage also includes Jemez Pueblo and Navajo ancestry.  She was adopted by a white couple when she was 10 years old, after spending four years in seven different foster placements.  Though ultimately landing in a home where she was physically safe and materially secure, she struggled throughout her adolescence and was eventually admitted into a behavioral residential treatment facility, where she completed her last two years of high school.  Coyote companions were the least of the things that confused her. 

For some 45 years, adoptions like Krupnick’s have been governed by a landmark federal law, the Indian Child Welfare Act. Enacted in 1978, ICWA regulates adoption and foster placement for Native American children who don’t live on reservation lands — the vast majority, owing to the fact that some 87 percent of Native peoples have moved off those lands. The law was designed to end the long and terrible history of involuntarily separating Native children from their families and to do what’s in the best interest of each child.

Veronica Krupnick, outside the state capitol in Santa Fe, where she works today as a Leadership Analyst. Michael Benanav/Searchlight New Mexico

ICWA strives to keep children within their families, clans, and communities. Today, Native American tribes and child welfare organizations hail its success with near unanimity. It is widely regarded as the gold standard for child welfare regulations, and states have modeled their own laws for non-Native kids after it to one degree or another.

An upcoming U.S. Supreme Court decision is casting a shadow on all that. The high court will soon rule in Brackeen v. Haaland, in which plaintiffs seek to strike down ICWA, alleging that it discriminates on the basis of race and violates the Constitution in other ways, as well. The case arose from the Texas court system, where Jennifer and Chad Brackeen, a white couple seeking to adopt a Navajo girl, sued to make it easier for non-Native families to adopt Native American children. A decision is expected by the end of June.

Much is at stake. In the big picture, some of the legal challenges to ICWA strike at the very foundation of Indian law, or Title 25 — a voluminous compilation of federal codes governing nearly every aspect of life on tribal lands. Many of these laws are rooted in centuries-old interpretations of the Constitution’s Commerce Clause that, among other things, give Congress the power to regulate and protect certain tribal activities. Lawyers for the Brackeens, along with conservative groups such as the Goldwater Institute, argue that Native American child custody issues are not among them.

Should the high court rule that it was indeed beyond the authority of Congress to enact ICWA in the first place — by narrowing the conventional understanding of the Commerce Clause — a swath of other laws could fall, too. 

A skeptical Justice Neil Gorsuch suggested during oral argument in November that these could include Native American health care provisions, religious liberties, rights to access sacred sites and tribal environmental regulations. “There would be a lot that would be bitten out of Title 25,” he said. “We’d be busy for the next many years striking things down.” 

The court could conclude that Congress didn’t violate the Commerce Clause, but overreached in more limited ways, overturning ICWA without the alarming ripple effects.

But if the justices rule that ICWA violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment — concluding that it is a “race-based law” — the consequences could be catastrophic, many Native American advocates fear.

“Indian law is based on the principle that tribes are sovereign nations that have a government-to-government relationship with the United States,” said Beth Wright, a staff attorney at the Native American Rights Fund and an enrolled member of Laguna Pueblo. “If this is reduced to a racial classification, all rights that tribes and tribal people enjoy are also subject to attack. They’re attacking tribal sovereignty at its core.”

Wright fears that this would spawn wholesale assaults on Indian Country, such as environmental and economic exploitation by corporations eager to tap into natural resources and casinos on Native land. She points out that the law firm representing the Brackeens pro bono also represents Chevron and some of the largest gaming companies in the world. 

Opponents of ICWA dismiss such concerns as exaggerated. Their only targets, they say, are Native child welfare regulations.

In New Mexico, Native American adoptions and foster care are regulated by an especially robust version of ICWA called the Indian Family Protection Act. As a state law, the Act will remain intact unless the Supreme Court strikes down ICWA as a violation of the Equal Protection Clause – in which case it too would likely be thrown out as race-based, according to attorneys on both sides of the debate.

“The separation of Indigenous people has been used as a tool of genocide, a form of violence against our community and our children,” said Angel Charley, executive director of the Coalition to Stop Violence Against Native Women. Charley is pictured here outside the San José de la Laguna Mission Church, in Laguna Pueblo. Michael Benanav/Searchlight New Mexico

A complex welter of issues

Beyond the tangle of legal matters, the Supreme Court case delves into the evocative terrain of historical trauma, race, identity, cultural biases — and the very meaning of family. 

The moral heart of the Brackeens’ argument is that ICWA, despite its good intentions, actually discriminates against Native children by limiting their options for adoptive and foster families and making “genetics and ancestry” the key criteria for placement. The Brackeens themselves, who are evangelical Christians, fostered and ultimately adopted a boy of Navajo and Cherokee parentage in 2018, following what they described as a religious calling. They have been fighting to adopt his younger half-sister, who they have fostered for most of her four years, sharing custody with a great-aunt who lives on the Navajo Nation.

ICWA mandates that child welfare agencies should first try to settle Native children with other family members. If that’s not possible, they should next try to place children with another family from their tribe, then with a family from another tribe, and lastly in a non-Native household. Exceptions are made on a case-by-case basis, when in the best interest of the child. But the Brackeens contend that these preferences harm Native children by steering them away from adoptive families that might be optimal but are farther down the list.

Among the many who disagree are 497 tribes, dozens of children’s rights organizations, 87 members of Congress, the ACLU, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Psychological Association and other groups that have filed or joined amicus briefs in support of ICWA.

There is ample evidence dating back decades that removing Native children from Native society can cause “untold social and psychological consequences,” according to the brief filed by 180 tribes.  Another brief, filed by Casey Family Programs and 26 other child welfare and adoption organizations from around the country, highlights ICWA’s crucial benefits. 

Citing outcomes data, the brief points out that, by favoring placement with blood relatives, clan relations or close family friends, Native foster children are less likely than non-Native children to be shuffled around from one setting to another, resulting in “fewer mental health disorders, and better well-being, while minimizing trauma.” They also have a better chance than non-Native kids of landing a permanent home. 

A system “that does not prioritize family integrity and community ties, invites a return to the days when courts unthinkingly presumed that an Indian child’s best interests were served by placement with a middle-class, non-Indian family,” the brief adds. 

Wright, the lawyer with the Native American Rights Fund, put it bluntly: “The other side doesn’t really care about Indian children.”

In the late 1960s and early ’70s, studies found that up to 35 percent of Native children were in Anglo foster homes, adoptive homes, or institutions — typically removed from their families without due process. Indigenous children were also forcibly placed in boarding schools, including one on the Navajo Nation that opened in 1883. Its stated goal: “To remove the Navajo child from the influence of his savage parents.” Photo courtesy of the National Archives and Records Administration

Who am I?

For Native child welfare advocates in New Mexico, the most important feature of ICWA’s placement preferences is its attempt to address the deep, existential questions faced by children who find themselves separated from their parents. 

“Where do I come from? Who are my people? Who am I? Anyone who has interacted with the foster care system can identify with wondering about these things,” said Angel Charley, of Laguna Pueblo. As executive director of the Coalition to Stop Violence Against Native Women, Charley provided input into the drafting of New Mexico’s Indian Family Protection Act of 2022; she also works on improving communication between Native foster families and the Children, Youth and Families Department, the agency responsible for foster care in New Mexico.

“We need to insure ‘belonging’ for little ones who are removed from families for circumstances that are beyond their control,” Charley said in a phone interview. “Indigenous people have language, culture, ceremony. We’re so grounded in belonging and to our ancestors and the land. For a child not to have access to those ways of being is detrimental. 

“I know many adults who grew up with no connection to community and are struggling to figure out how to connect. Kinship and culture can’t be replicated outside of our communities. Belonging is more important than material wealth.”

Veronica Krupnik’s complex story bears this out, though parts of it, if taken in isolation, could bolster the argument against ICWA’s placement preferences: At age nine, she was being fostered by a family member, but the situation turned abusive. She was then placed with a white couple, on an emergency basis, and they eventually adopted her. 

Her adoptive parents were “wonderful providers,” sending her to top private schools, she said. “They wanted me to be educated and have every opportunity.” But she spiraled as she entered her teen years, rebelling against a restrictive household where she never felt entirely at home. “It wasn’t just their fault,” she reflected. “I was a traumatized kid.”

Exacerbating those traumas was her sense of being thrust into a world in which she didn’t belong. “It’s not just one thing. It’s how you speak, how you dress, how you wake up in the morning, how you eat dinner,” Krupnick said. “In Native cultures, ways of life are more abstract; in Western culture, everything needs to have an answer, everything happens on a timeline, there’s a lot less grey.” 

What’s more, leaving her community as a child, she didn’t know much about her own culture, leaving her ungrounded, unrooted.

Catherine Begaye, the ICWA court’s presiding judge, in New Mexico’s Second Judicial District.

State fails Indigenous children

Though New Mexico, with the passage of IFPA, has emerged as a leader in Native American child welfare, it hasn’t yet lived up to its aspirations. A 2021 survey by the Children, Youth and Families Department found that the state has fallen far short of meeting several of its obligations to Native kids in foster care. Only about a quarter of them found preferred placements with family or tribal members, the survey revealed.

The critical bottleneck is the shortage of licensed Native foster families. While efforts are now being made to increase Native participation — in part by employing more culturally sensitive ways of communicating with and evaluating households — raising these numbers will take time.

The major exception to these deficiencies is in Bernalillo County, where a special ICWA court was established in 2020. Headed by Judge Catherine Begaye, a member of the Navajo Nation, the court has seen more than 100 children come through its doors: 86 percent have gone into preferred placements; 60 percent have been reunified with their parents; none of the families that were reunified have come back before the court; and no parental rights have been terminated, court data show.

Judge Begaye chokes up with emotion when speaking of her hopes and dreams for the children she sees, and she uses the powers of the bench to support each one. This can include helping extended family members become licensed foster parents, working in tandem with tribes and ordering the Children, Youth and Families Department to ensure that kids have the opportunity to participate in dances and other ceremonies. Begaye calls doing what’s best for Native children simply “following the law.” 

If ICWA is overturned on equal protection grounds, this special court will likely cease to function, at least in its current form. Throughout New Mexico and the nation, protocols for handling Native child welfare cases will enter unknown territory. The state doesn’t have any backup plans to address this possibility. 

Krupnick hopes it won’t come to that. She knows the value of the very things that ICWA was designed to protect and believes other Native children do, too. “As a kid plopped from one community to another, that took away a really essential part of my identity. I couldn’t figure out where I was going until I found this core piece of myself.”

Reconnecting with her culture and her family of origin, and making Native friends, has helped Krupnick heal. “When I go back to Hopi, something in me knows I’m home. I have a physical response that I don’t have anywhere else, except maybe at my great-grandma’s house in Jemez. It’s like my body takes a great big sigh of relief,” she said. Being around other Native people, she added, means “not having to explain.” 

She now volunteers with and advocates for Native children who are in the child welfare system and serves on the board of directors of CASA First – which trains court-appointed advocates for foster children in the First Judicial District. Recently, she also took a new job in the New Mexico’s House Majority Office. 

And she still has close encounters with coyotes from time to time, she said. “But now I can lean on it, instead of it being weird and confusing.”

 

Michael Benanav is a writer, photographer and digital storyteller based in northern New Mexico.

CLICK OLDER POSTS (above) to see more news

CLICK OLDER POSTS  (above) to see more news

MEGWETCH THANK YOU

HUGE Thank you for visiting this blog and sharing this with your kin. It's appreciated. Contact Trace anytime! Use the form below.

BOOKSHOP

Please use BOOKSHOP to buy our titles. We will not be posting links to Amazon.

Popular Posts

To Veronica Brown

Veronica, we adult adoptees are thinking of you today and every day. We will be here when you need us. Your journey in the adopted life has begun, nothing can revoke that now, the damage cannot be undone. Be courageous, you have what no adoptee before you has had; a strong group of adult adoptees who know your story, who are behind you and will always be so.

OUR HISTORY

OUR HISTORY
BOOK 5: Lost Children of the Indian Adoption Projects