This blog was a backup for American Indian Adopteesblog
USE THE SEARCH BAR or SEARCH TOPICS at bottom of this blog
If you need support
Support Info: If you are a Survivor and need emotional support, a national crisis line is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week: Residential School Survivor Support Line: 1-866-925-4419. Additional Health Support Information: Emotional, cultural, and professional support services are also available to Survivors and their families through the Indian Residential Schools Resolution Health Support Program. Services can be accessed on an individual, family, or group basis.” These & regional support phone numbers are found at https://nctr.ca/contact/survivors/ .
MY EMAIL: tracelara@pm.me
Kelly Church, “Before and After” (2024) (photo by Michigan Photography)
On the occasion of the major exhibition showcasing renowned black ash basket weavers, Kelly Church & Cherish Parrish: In Our Words, An Intergenerational Dialogue,Stamps Gallery is proud to organize an important public discussion
on the tragic legacy of American-Indian Boarding Schools in the United
States and the intergenerational trauma and suffering they inflicted on
Indigenous communities. Church and Parrish explore the consequences of
this time through their boundary-breaking basketry as they pay homage to
their community’s resilience, strength, and bravery.
Rochelle Ettawageshik is
a citizen of the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians and serves
as vice chair of the tribe’s child welfare commission. She currently
sits on the board of directors for the National Indian Child Welfare
Association and is vice president of the Michigan Indian Education
Council. Ettawageshik recently retired from the State of Michigan as the
director of Native American Affairs in the Child and Family Services
Administration, where she developed policies to improve services to
American Indian families in Michigan.
Benedict Hinmon is
the Director at Saginaw Chippewa Indian Tribe of Michigan. Little
Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians. Mount Pleasant, Michigan. Hinmon is
the grandson of Obwaandiak (Chief Pontiac) and comes from a proud
family of Michigan Anishinaabe.
Matthew L.M. Fletcher
is the Harry Burns Hutchins Collegiate Professor of Law at Michigan
Law. He teaches and writes in the areas of federal Indian law, American
Indian tribal law, Anishinaabe legal and political philosophy,
constitutional law, federal courts, and legal ethics. He also sits as
the chief justice of the Pokagon Band of Potawatomi Indians, the Poarch
Band of Creek Indians, and the Grand Traverse Band of Ottawa and
Chippewa Indians.
Wenona T. Singel is an
Associate Professor of Law at Michigan State University College of Law
and the Director of the Indigenous Law & Policy Center. Her research
and writing address issues related to Tribal Sovereignty and Indigenous
Rights. She is working on a book about the intergenerational impact of
federal Indian law and policy on Native families.
On
view through December 7, this exhibition centers the subjectivities of
two contemporary Indigenous artists whose practices have sustained and
bolstered the relevance of the age-old Anishinaabe practice of black ash
basket-making in the 21st century. Kelly Church and Cherish Parrish
explore the themes of Native women’s labor as carriers of culture, the
legacy of boarding schools, treaties, and stories from ancestors who
walked on through their work.
Curated by Srimoyee Mitra with Curatorial Assistant Zoi Crampton.
Rosebud Bear Schneider and her son, Sonny, use a push pole to harvest rice. Credit: Antonio Cosme
Along the shores of the Detroit River and in almost every Michigan waterway, manoomin, or wild rice, used to grow abundantly.
Sacred and central to Great Lakes tribes’ origin stories, manoomin
has largely disappeared due to development, pollution and other factors.
But Indigenous people remain and they are bringing wild rice traditions
back to Detroit.
On Sunday, Historic Fort Wayne is hosting a rice camp where
participants will craft wooden sticks for wild rice harvesting, “dance”
on the rice in moccasins to remove the hulls and share a meal, among
other activities.
Rosebud Bear Schneider, a Southwest Detroit native and member of the
Lac Courte Oreilles Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians, has been
working for 10 years on cultivating Indigenous food sovereignty in
Detroit. In the past, she would cook and serve wild rice at events to
reconnect people to their traditional ways.
“You would see a full room of people light up and get really excited,
like, ‘I haven’t eaten that in a long time,’” said Schneider, who is a
co-director of education and engagement at local farming nonprofit Keep
Growing Detroit.
Teaching people how to process the rice will deepen that connection
even further, she said. It’s the first time she can think of that the
teaching was offered in Detroit during her lifetime.
“It’s another step to this path that we’re on to connect to this
food, connect to our ways, connect to our spirit and connect to the
land,” said Schneider, who will process manoomin for the first time this
weekend.
Teachings say Ojibwe
people migrating from the East were told to establish where they found
food that grew in water. They found wild rice in Lake Superior and made
the region home. The rice grew abundantly along the Detroit River and in
other parts of the city before 97% of the city’s coastal wetlands were destroyed for development in the late 20th century and 85% of the city’s inland streams were buried.
The decimation has contributed to a disconnect between local tribes and the sacred grain, according to rice camp organizers.
“Manoomin, the food that grows on the water – it’s the whole reason
that we Anishinaabe are even here,” said east side resident Jared Ten
Brink, a member of the Nottawaseppi Huron Band of the Potawatomi and one
of the event’s collaborators. “It’s so important to who we are, but I
talked with my own family members, and most of them don’t know anything
about it.”
Manoomin harvest. Credit: Antonio Cosme
The closest place to Detroit where traditional wild rice harvesting
occurs is several hours up north, creating a barrier for Detroit Natives
to reconnect to their traditions. The wild rice camp hosted by the
Detroit Indigenous People’s Alliance, Black to the Land Coalition and
the Ecumenical Theological Seminary seeks to close the gap.
“We want people to be able to experience wild rice here in Detroit,”
said Antonio Cosme, co-founder of Black to the Land Coalition, a
nonprofit that helps Black and brown people return to the land. Just a
few weeks ago Cosme traveled to Lac du Flambeau, Wisconsin, to learn
traditional manoomin harvest methods.
Fort Wayne, the induction center for soldiers for every conflict from the Civil War to Vietnam, is the site of Native burial mounds
and where members of the Potawatomi tribe once lived. On Sunday,
attendees will smell the toasted rice, feel it beneath their feet and
see it with their eyes.
“It’s hard to really understand something if you can’t actually get
your hands into it and do it, so this is a great opportunity where we
can bring this to people who wouldn’t otherwise necessarily be able to
have this experience,” said Ten Brink.
Regrowing wild rice
At the state level, efforts are being made to regrow wild rice and recognize its importance.
Last year, Gov. Gretchen Whitmer signed legislation making wild rice the state’s official native grain, the first state
to designate a native grain. In November, more than 70 groups from
across the state gave input on a draft of the Michigan Tribal-State
Manoomin Stewardship Plan, a joint partnership between the Michigan Wild
Rice Initiative and U-M Water Center, funded with a $100,000 state
grant from 2022.
The plan is still being finalized, said Ten Brink, who worked on it
as a PhD student at U-U-M. Reseeding Detroit and Michigan with manoomin
is complicated for a number of reasons, he said.
“You can’t just harvest manoomin seeds from some place and go out and start tossing them,” he said.
Jared Ten Brink harvesting rice at Tawas Lake in Michigan. Credit: Nigora Erkeava
Specific varieties need to be used for different locations. Reseeding
can be made challenging by water current speeds and temperature,
pollution, and species like phragmites, which take over an ecosystem and
make it hard for native species like wild rice to thrive. It’s even
harder in an urban setting like Detroit, where many waterways have been
buried, said Ten Brink, including Bloody Run on the city’s east side near where he lives.
“It’s enclosed in a storm drain, it doesn’t exist as a river,” he
said. “Those are places where river rice would have been growing, but
we don’t even have the rivers to restore it.”
Another challenge is figuring out how to work together on the plan, he said.
“Wild rice restoration – a lot of the knowledge is held within the
tribes, but a lot of the resources are with the cities, counties, states
and the federal government.”
And, climate change is an increasing threat. In Lac du Flambeau, the rice was struggling, Cosme added.
“You go to a rice bed and you’ll see that it’s a lot of water,
there’s not much seed to harvest,” he said. “You start knocking the
rice, and it’s not much coming into your boat.”
The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources confirmed in September that the wild rice production this year was significantly lower than average
due to a warmer winter and heavy June storms. Factors that are made
more likely due to climate change, which Ten Brink hopes to educate
people about at Sunday’s rice camp.
“In Southeast Michigan, we will see more and more severe weather as a
result of warmer temperatures and that severe weather has a couple of
big impacts for wild rice,” he said, primarily increased water levels
and water temperatures.
For non-Natives interested in the camp and the topic, Schneider wants
them to know that Indigenous people still exist in Detroit and need
support.
“We are still very much a thriving community and we still very much
need that solidarity and support when it comes to these huge issues like
feeding ourselves, having our neighbors recognize that we are still
here and that Indigenous People’s Day is an actual and important day,”
she said.
The Sunday camp runs from 1-6 p.m. Registration is required and urban Natives will be prioritized.
SF1279/SF2995/HF1778.[ENACTED!]Unrestricted equal rights bill that dismantles Minnesota’s forty-five year history of inequality. These bills are unrestricted equal rights bill that are generally identical to bills filed in the prior two legislative sessions. Sen. Erin Maye Quade, a DFL (Democratic) legislator, is the chief author of the Senate bill, and Rep. Steve Elkins is the chief author of the House bill. The bills constitute a necessary simplification of the law by eliminating Minnesota’s incomprehensibly complicated and discriminatory intermediary system, the first such system in the United States and one that has been in place since 1977. Minnesota Coalition for Adoption Reform and Minnesota-based Adoptee Rights Law Center are working collaboratively on the bill. The House bill has been assigned to the Health Finance and Policy Committee. The Senate bill was reported out of the Judiciary and Public Safety Committee and heard in the Health and Human Services Committee. It is now part of the Senate HHS omnibus appropriations bill (SF2995), which passed the full Senate on April 18. After negotiations, the adoptee birth record provisions in the Senate version of SF2995 were included and approved as part of the the overall HHS omnibus bill. The legislature passed the omnibus bill on May 22, the last day of the regular session, and Governor Tim Walz signed the bill into law on May 24. Minnesota will now become the 15th state in the country to restore equal rights to all adopted people born in the state. The law is fully effective on July 1, 2024.
Oregon
SB573 [ENACTED!] Allows a biological parent who was omitted or listed incorrectly to be added to an original (pre-adoptive) birth certificate. This bill has been in the Oregon legislature for about three sessions now, doggedly pursued by an adult adoptee who wants the correct factual information listed on her own original birth certificate. The bill, carried by Senator Sara Gelser Blouin, would allow addition or correction of a birthparent on the OBC if approved through an administrative determination of paternity or parentage. DNA evidence is required, along with a $100 filing fee. The first hearing on the bill was January 23, 2023, before the Senate Committee on Human Services, chaired by Senator Gelser Blouin. The bill was then delayed for consideration to work out issues arising out of the process to approve corrections to the birth record. It was reported out favorably on March 6 after the bill was simplified to avoid a court process. It passed the Senate on March 13, on a 28-1 vote and is now in the House, where it was heard on April 24 in the Early Childhood and Human Services Committee and subsequently recommended for passage by the House. The House passed the bill on May 23, 2023, and Governor Tina Kotek signed it into law on June 6, 2023. It is effective on January 1, 2024.
Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson points to one of 5,703 state flag designs posted in the Utah office in Millcreek, Utah, 2022 | Photo by Carter Williams, KSL.com, St. George News
SALT LAKE CITY — Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson has joined a number of Utah leaders voicing support for the Indian Child Welfare Act and enacting legal protections for Native American adoptions at the state level.
Henderson recently tweeted her support for the act. The law, often referred to as ICWA, was passed in 1978 to safeguard against extensive forced separation of Native children from their families and communities. It is currently being challenged in the Supreme Court.
“A tribe is a political and governmental classification, not a racial one,” Henderson tweeted. “Utah supports the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) and will seek to codify it to protect the eight federally recognized Native American tribes in our state.”
Codifying ICWA in Utah law has widespread support, including from Utah’s eight federally recognized tribes, the Indian Law Section of the Utah State Bar and the Utah Native American Legislative Liaison Committee, which voted unanimously in November to introduce an ICWA bill in the 2023 legislative session. Utah Attorney General Sean Reyes was also a part of a bipartisan coalition that submitted an amicus brief in support of ICWA, arguing that the law fosters good relationships between states and tribal governments.
U.S. Supreme Court's pending decision on a Native American adoption law will impact Mississippi Choctaws. Credit: Courtesy of the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians
A challenge to a decades-old federal law has the potential to impact tribes around the country, including those in Mississippi.
The Indian Child Welfare Act governs child custody of Native children. If a child is removed from their parents, the act sets preferences to place the child with another family member, another member of the tribe or a different tribe.
The case Brackeen v. Halaandbefore the Supreme Court challenges these preferences. Three pairs of non-Native foster parents and three states are suing the federal government and five tribes, arguing the act discriminates against non-Native people based on race.
Tribes including the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians are watching the case and see more at stake than adoption.
“As the only federally recognized tribe in the State of Mississippi, our 11,000 plus members are descendants of those members who chose to remain here in Mississippi to preserve our cultural heritage on our ancestral homelands,” the tribe said in a statement. “Today, just as in the past, the preservation and security of our tribe, and our tribal children and families are of utmost importance.”
“I look forward to taking all of my professional experience and diligently applying it to the work ahead of me,” Maldonado said.
“This is a moment of importance not just for me, but for all of Indian Country as the Governor’s wisdom in this appointment sends a message about the critical importance of the work of tribal courts,” Maldonado added. “I am grateful to the Governor and her team, and I look forward to giving all of Michigan my best.”
I think of greatest importance is Maldonado’s work on the Indian Child Welfare Act. The act was designed to try and keep native children in welfare cases with their family, extended family or a tribal nation. The constitutionality of the law is currently before the U.S. Supreme Court.
As a tribal member she brings a Native sensibility to the state appeals court.
Sierra Charwood, 19, said the possibility of overturning the act is especially scary since her great-grandmother was forced to go to one of the boarding schools the federal government used to forcibly removed American Indian children from their homes in order to assimilate them into white culture. Because of that, Charwood lost the chance to learn more about her language and culture because it was not passed down, she said.
"It directly affected me that way — I don't have access to my language, my history, my roots," she said.
Charwood and other American Indian students fear that if the act were overturned, it could bring back boarding schools.
"Doing this would be taking multiple steps back, and with placing Native children in homes that aren't equipped for them and cannot better them," she said. "If this happens again, we're going to see a big hit to our community."
If ICWA is overturned, it could have ramifications affecting generations of Native children, Littlest Feather said.
It was a historic ceremony: U.S. Secretary of the Interior Deb Haaland, the first tribal citizen to hold the position, swearing in Bryan Newland, a citizen of the Bay Mills Indian Community, as Assistant Secretary of Indian Affairs.
For the first time in American history, tribal citizens lead the U.S. in its government-to-government relationship with American Indian and Alaska Native Nations.
As assistant secretary, Newland becomes the highest-ranking official in the Bureau of Indian Affairs. One of the oldest federal agencies, the Bureau of Indian Affairs exists to enhance the quality of life, promote economic opportunity, and carry out the federal responsibility to protect and improve the trust assets of American Indians, tribal governments and Alaska Natives.
Newland’s experiences as an attorney for tribal governments, a policy advisor in the Obama Administration, the Chief Judge of the Bay Mills Indian Community, and the President of the Bay Mills Indian Community make him especially qualified to lead the Bureau of Indian Affairs. The Bay Mills Indian Community is located near the Upper Peninsula's Whitefish Bay, on the shores of Lake Superior.
Newland is uniquely positioned to advance the Biden Administration’s priorities of upholding the United States’ trust responsibility to tribal nations, strengthening the nation-to-nation relationship between the United States and Indian tribes, and working to empower tribal nations to govern their own communities and make their own decisions.
In leading the BIA, Newland will draw on many of his own experiences as a tribal leader to improve the relationship between tribal governments and the United States.
Having just finished serving his community as tribal president, Newland knows firsthand the struggles faced by tribal governments in developing sustainable economies, protecting their territories, and serving their communities. He showed tremendous leadership during the pandemic, urging the BIA to provide adequate testing in Indian country and ensuring that tribal governments received funding allocated to them under the CARES Act.
His advocacy for federal government accountability to Indian country demonstrates his deep understanding of the trust relationship between the United States government and Indian tribes. This understanding will serve him well as he takes on a key role in implementing the trust relationship and assisting tribal governments as they recover from a pandemic, which has disproportionately affected their communities.
Newland’s vision for helping tribal governments stems from his knowledge that tribal communities are best served when they are empowered to craft their own solutions to problems. Like President Biden and Secretary Haaland, he is dedicated to advancing the federal government’s commitment to ensuring tribal consultation on and input into federal policymaking. As a former Tribal President, he brings key insights into what works for tribal leaders in this process as he seeks to improve it.
Newland shares many of the values of other tribal leaders and will prioritize them as Assistant Secretary of Indian Affairs. Raised in his traditional Anishinaabek homeland along the shores of Lake Superior, he values the restoring and strengthening of tribal homelands so that every Native person has a place to call home. He understands that tribal homelands must be economically viable and has emphasized the need to restore tribal wealth to tribal communities so that they will thrive for generations yet to come. As tribal president, he sought to protect his own tribal homeland by vocally opposing Enbridge’s Line 5.
In addition to his on the ground experiences in Indian country, Newland understands the challenges facing the BIA, which has not always served Indian country well.
He acknowledges that the agency has contributed to the state of affairs in Indian country and sees undoing colonization as intergenerational work. He has emphasized the importance of children to Native communities and acknowledged the incredible harm done to tribal families, cultures, and communities when their children are removed.
As assistant secretary, he will support enforcement of the Indian Child Welfare Act, which prevents the unnecessary removal of Indian children from their tribal communities.
Newland’s appointment, alongside Haaland's historic appointment, will usher in a transformative new era in federal Indian affairs. As head of the BIA during an administration devoted to tribal sovereignty and racial equity, Newland can start to undo the colonization that has pervaded federal Indian law and policy from within.
Kirsten Matoy Carlson is a professor of law and adjunct associate professor of political science at the Wayne State University Law School, and is a leading authority on federal Indian law and legislation.
The Indian Child Welfare Act, or ICWA, basically provides Tribes with an opportunity to intervene when state child welfare and adoption agencies consider whether or not to remove a Native child from a home. The children can be enrolled citizens of the Tribe or be eligible for membership status.
Alaska Native Justice Center policy director Alex Cleghorn says ICWA was passed in 1978 in response to the disproportionate removal of Native children from their homes, families and communities.
“They were primarily being placed in the homes of non-Native people and growing up without a connection to their culture or to the communities,” said Cleghorn, who worked as a Tribal attorney for much of his career, is a citizen of Tangirnaq Native Village and serves on the board of directors for Koniag Incorporated regional Native corporation. “I believe the Alaska Native culture is something that is a strength."
The Alaska Native Justice Center is an advocacy organization that provides Alaska Native people with direct services in education, victim advocacy, Tribal court assistance and more.
(Disclosure: The Alaska Native Justice Center, KNBA and Koahnic Broadcast Corporation are tenants of Cook Inlet Tribal Council.)
“They seem to believe that being a Native person is solely a racial classification, which ignores many years of precedent and legal rulings that as a Native person, our relationship with our Tribe is that of a citizen who works in government.”
Erin Dougherty Lynch is a staff attorney at Native American Rights Fund, a nonprofit legal organization that holds the U.S. governement to its treaty obligations with Tribes as well as laws that affect Native people. Lynch works on a variety of federal Native issues including Tribal jurisdiction, sovereignty – and child welfare.
She says the plaintiffs in the Brackeen case argue that ICWA is a law based on race: “That it's a race-based law that provides preference to extra services to Native children, to provide preferences to Native families, which should be struck down by the Supreme Court on an equal protection ground.”
But Lynch says ICWA, along with the bulk of federal Indian policy, is grounded in a political relationship between governments – between federal and Tribal governments, and between Tribes and their citizens.
ICWA is a federal law that establishes a floor-level basis for reviewing Native child adoption cases. Some states passed their own ICWA laws, but those laws must offer additional benefits – not change or remove the application of federal law: “States can never do less than what's in the federal law, but they can always do more,” Lynch says.
For example, Washington state has its own ICWA law.
“(Compacts are) another kind of tool that we've had in Alaska where Tribes are working, have compacted on a government-to-government relationship with the state government and with the goal of providing more culturally appropriate services to children in the state's child welfare system.”
Tribal leaders often testify at Alaska Legislature hearings that Alaska Native children are over-represented in the foster care system.
According to the Alaska Tribal Child Welfare Compact (2017), even though Alaska Natives represent less than 20 percent of children in the state, they make up more than half the children placed in foster care.
Cleghorn says the Brackeen case illustrates that more states should be looking at state-based ICWA protections.
“If the federal law is going to continue to be under attack, it may be time to look at a state equivalent to ensure that we continue to recognize Tribes recognized as the gold standard in child welfare and protection, and that those protective factors of having children connected to their culture, the Tribes and their families are important and should be enshrined in law.”
The Brackeen lawsuit worked its way to the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, which covers the federal judicial district in Louisiana, Mississippi, and Texas.
A three-member judges panel heard the case and upheld the constitutionality of ICWA, but with partial dissent. That allowed the plaintiffs to request and receive a full bench – or en banc – decision.
Sixteen judges split down the middle and wrote a 325-page decision. Because of the split, Lynch says the decision largely impacts cases in that district’s region – and wouldn’t affect Alaska directly.
Alaska Native Justice Center policy director Cleghorn is also confident the split decision should not impact ICWA cases in Alaska or in states that are outside of the Fifth Circuit.
“I also think it's important to keep our eyes open for those of us who do work in this area and represent Tribes in this area, because sometimes there are misguided attempts to import reasoning or to import reasoning or decisions that may not apply,” Cleghorn said.
For now, legal experts and Tribes will keep an eye on the Brackeen case, and will be on the lookout for others, Lynch said.
"Certainly, if the case ends up going up before the United States Supreme Court, what the Supreme Court determines will have an effect in Alaska. But right now, you know, state and Tribal child welfare workers who are involved in state child welfare cases don't have to worry about this opinion."
But Lynch says it is possible that Alaska Native children living in the Fifth Circuit could be affected.
“When you start talking about places that are in states that are in the Fifth Circuit, like Texas and Louisiana and Mississippi, then the whether the case applies is a maybe,” Lynch said. “Which I know might be sort of unsatisfying, but there are sort of these general principles that federal courts don't necessarily tell state courts what to do. And so it sort of depends state-to- state as to whether or not this is going to have precedential effect in the Fifth Circuit. But for our purposes in Alaska, we we can ignore this decision for now.”
The legal experts and attorneys following the case worked to unravel its many threads and how each one would impact ICWA or their understanding of the case and law.
“It definitely took us a few days to sit down and, like, sort it all out,” Lynch said. “We literally had to map out every issue that had been brought up in the case and then sit down and go through all of the opinions and see how folks had come down. I know the court in those first few pages did issue like a per curiam opinion where they tried to give a synopsis of where the whole thing had come down. But you still really have to sit down and go through it all. And it's complicated for the lawyers.”
The ICWALawCenter provides legal services and advocacy to Indian families impacted by the child protection system. ICWALawCenter Suite 104 1730 Clifton Place Minneapolis, MN 55403. Telephone: 612-879-9165 Fax: 612-879-0323 E-mail: info@icwlc.org.
Six states (Iowa, Michigan, Minnesota, Nebraska, Oklahoma and Washington) have enacted their own Indian Child Welfare Act, adopting provisions from the federal ICWA in whole or in part. Other states have adopted some provisions, most commonly, the definition of "Indian child" and the notification requirements.
The Indian Child Welfare Act passed into law in 1978. The law protects American Indian and Alaska Native (AI/AN) children in state child welfare systems and helps them remain connected to their families, cultures, and communities.
The Michigan Supreme Court ceremonially praised the efforts of family court participants, including Tribal leaders, for restoring children to their families on June 24, 2016, in Lansing. Five judges from Michigan’s Tribal State Federal Judicial Forum were present. According to the article, more than half of foster care children were returned to their families in 2015. In 2015, more than half of the 8,000 plus children in foster care were reunited with their families. As several people noted throughout the event, reunification is always the goal of the judicial system, and deciding to terminate parental rights is a last resort. Friday’s event celebrated the major efforts courts and the state are making to put parents back on the path to caring for their own.
By MICHELLE MERLIN | Here, from the Grand Traverse Record-Eagle.
Paul Raphael was just a kid in first grade when it happened. He attended the Holy Childhood of Jesus School in Harbor Springs — a boarding school among hundreds nationwide that operated for more than a century — where Native American children were sent to become “civilized” by nuns. The nuns were teaching table manners. One asked: What happens after you butter your bread and cut it into four pieces? “I said, ‘you eat it,’” said Raphael, a member of the Grand Traverse Band of Ottawa and Chippewa Indians. “I remember the nun coming over and smacking me. She smacked me hard and I fell out of my chair.” Raphael was so upset he never did learn the answer; he’d never been hit before. But he did take one thing away from watching nuns abuse his classmates over the next several years: “I knew that if I had kids, I wouldn’t treat them the way they were treating us,” Raphael said.
Not just a relic Memories of Holy Childhood and other Indian boarding schools are still fresh in the minds of Grand Traverse Band members. The three-story building in Harbor Springs operated until 1983, long after other Indian boarding schools run by non-natives closed down. Some families, like Raphael’s, sent their children to the schools because they thought it was the only way to keep their family together. Some sent their children to the schools because they thought it was the best way to feed their families, and others sent their children so they would learn to read and write. Tribal children from the region for the most part were not allowed to wear their own clothes or speak their language, Anishinabemowen. Many Indian schools like Holy Childhood started as church-run mission schools designed to teach children in their own language, but their objectives changed in the late 1880s. The federal government took control of Indian education in the U.S. and the facilities shifted from mission schools to boarding schools, said Eric Hemenway, the director of archives and records for the Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians. He focused his studies on the school in Harbor Springs.
“As long as the family nucleus was kept intact, they’d keep speaking their language and keeping their traditions,” Hemenway said. “The government wanted to break this, essentially.”
The schools often used brutal tactics to impose mainstream culture on children and left a legacy of abuse from Pennsylvania to California. Nationwide the schools’ student population didn’t peak until the 1970s when more than 60,000 Native American children were enrolled, according to Amnesty International. John Petoskey, general counsel for the Grand Traverse Band, said the schools weren’t enough to whitewash the culture. The government then adopted the Dawes Act of 1887, which divided reservations into allotments for individuals. Excess land was given to outsiders, he said.Now members of the community are focused on healing the wounds left by the schools and other abuses. Tribal offices shut down for two days this month for a Gathering of Native Americans. The event allows native people to reclaim their histories, stories and ceremonies. It spotlights the community’s resilience. Raphael, who worked with tribal members battling addictions and became a peacemaker for youth in trouble, said he’s seen many tribal members turn to alcohol or drugs to forget the trauma of boarding schools. He said the abuse at the hands of nuns likely contributed to some former students’ abusive behavior toward women. “I think that spilled over into the community,” he said. He said boarding schools often are discussed at native gatherings, and it always bothered him and his classmates that sometimes they’re talked about as institutions of the past, something that was only experienced by people who are now dead. “There are people still alive who went to boarding school, who it had a negative impact on them,” Raphael said. “There are those who went to boarding school who are living in fear.” Raphael recalls one encounter with a former classmate who’d often been called on by the nuns to dole out punishment. The man saw Raphael and immediately stood to fight. “He said, ‘ever since I left boarding school, I’ve been afraid you guys were going to come back and get me at some point.’ He said, ‘I was so afraid I started drinking. I became an alcoholic out of fear,’” Raphael said. He assured the man that was not the case. It’s the kind of long-lasting cultural ripple many tribal members have become accustomed to in the three decades since the school in Harbor Springs closed. A community void JoAnne Cook, a Grand Traverse Band Tribal Council member, was the first in her family not to go to boarding school. Her mother, grandmother and older siblings all attended the schools.Cook, who graduated from Suttons Bay High School in 1985, said she didn’t know much about boarding schools until one of her friends was sent to one. They were 10 years old, and Cook thought the pair would have fun if they went together. She asked her mother if she could join her friend at boarding school. “I just remember the look my mom had on her face. I knew immediately I just asked her something that I shouldn’t have,” Cook said. Cook said she learned more about the schools as she grew older. Many families believed their children would be placed in foster care if they didn’t send them away to school. The Indian Child Welfare Act was passed in 1978, after Congress reviewed policies and found that Native American children were being taken from their parents at what John Petoskey described as an “alarming rate.” The act gave tribes more opportunities to intervene in parental rights cases. Both the boarding schools and foster care left behind a community devoid of children, and damaged a culture centered on family. Grandparents traditionally taught children values and language, but that system eroded while children were banned from speaking the language in school, Cook said. “Then you get to my generation that has had to live through that. We are kind of picking that all back up,” Cook said. She said the community has to remember its history but not get stuck in it. “A lot of native people say you have to know who you are; you have to know your story,” Cook said. Different experience Not everyone had a negative experience at boarding school. Elsie Dudley remembers her time at one as a needed escape from Suttons Bay when she was young. Other children and most of the teachers at the public school were prejudiced against natives, she said. She refused to go to class, and when the bus dropped her at school she wouldn’t follow her classmates. “I’d get off and walk back home, about three miles away,” she said. Dudley’s father decided to send her to Holy Childhood for the sixth grade in the late 1940s. She spent the next three years there. At first she tried to pull the same stunts, but one day a nun pulled her aside and explained they could teach her, as long as she was open to it. “I wanted to learn after that nun sat me down,” Dudley said. “They made it fun.” Dudley said that unlike others’ experiences, she was never discouraged from speaking her language. In fact, nuns taught her beading, leather work and other cultural crafts. Dudley never experienced abuse or saw any. She even wanted to be a nun when she left school, and later passed on what she learned to her children. “I showed them structure and that’s what I learned up there,” she said. Later generations Eva Petoskey said tribal members had a range of boarding school experiences. Some of her family members ran away, while others appreciated the food and structure. She considers herself a survivor of boarding schools, even though she never attended one. She knows people her age who were sent to them. Her mother went to a school in Mount Pleasant, and her grandmother to another in Carlisle, Pennsylvania. “I think as a public policy, as a policy of the United States government, it was misguided and harmful,” she said. “It was, I think, a violation of our human rights.” The Carlisle Indian Industrial Boarding School in Pennsylvania was established in 1879 by Richard Pratt, an army officer who is remembered for his philosophy: “Kill the Indian, save the man.” Petoskey said her grandmother made the trip by boat and train when she was 8 years old. She expected to find comfortable beds “like the white people” had, but found uncomfortable army-style barracks instead. Many children got sick and died, Petoskey said. Petoskey is a member of the Grand Traverse Band and the director of the Anishnaabek Healing Circle Access to Recovery Inter-Tribal Council of Michigan, a group that helps people struggling with substance abuse. She experienced the inter-generational trauma left in the wake of the boarding schools that’s common in the region’s tribal community.
“You have this underlying feeling you’re always fighting, about being inferior or insignificant,” she said.
She said many women her age were raised in foster care, orphanages or boarding schools. Petoskey and her husband swore off drugs and alcohol, but not all tribal members were able to make such a commitment. “I think that some of that internalized oppression that’s resulted from these violations of our human rights has resulted in those widespread problems,” she said. Cook said there’s still hope the tribal community can get through the boarding school era and become a healthier community. “We have things that our grandparents were trying to get for us and we were able to finally receive some of that,” Cook said. “Sometimes we’re kind of focused on what we don’t have, versus what we do.” Now Native Americans have to balance the push and pull between preserving the past and protecting the future. “Most of the time, society doesn’t set it up where you can really do both,” Petoskey said.
Here is “Reunification Day” from the Washtenaw County Legal News, Michigan.
An excerpt:
Justice McCormack acknowledged how moving the annual Adoption Day celebrations are and that “in a way, this is even more moving. “As I look around and talk with people today, I believe it’s a privilege to be a part of this celebration. What a tremendous accomplishment. In reading thousands of petitions, you come to understand the struggles that families are facing in this process and of what’s required of them. I know from personal experience and as a mother that parenting is incredibly hard work. Raising a family is hard even when things are going well let alone the curve balls thrown at families in the court process.” McCormack noted that parents “are only as happy as your unhappiest child.” “As an appellate judge, it isn’t often that I can look a parent in the face and say, ‘Well Done.’ So it’s nice to say that today. In spite of setbacks, you didn’t stop working to show your kids what it means to be a family. And as important as that accomplishment, you have shown your kids how to get through it when life throws you a curve ball.” Chairman Mandoka noted that during his involvement in the development of a tribal court system in Michigan, tribal leaders needed to address difficult family situations. “We wanted to make sure people could see more clearly when in a fog. In the fog, you feel lost, you make wrong decisions. We’ve all been a part of that. We have now developed a court system and a probation system to help struggling individuals see past that fog. “In the end, it’s always about a relationship. You can talk about models, plans and forecasts but it’s still all about the relationship; eye-to-eye contact and a handshake. “We all should make sure that we leave this earth a better place than how it was when we came into it, for our children. That’s what should drive us, should be our passion.” Judge Connors noted that those involved in child welfare work have defined the responsibility to three core accomplishments: safe children, strong families and supportive communities. “We are always looking at doing whatever furthers those key goals. One thing we have learned from Native American culture and tribal courts is the importance to come to your work with an internal balance. Only then can we bring the best that we have to a situation."
Convincing me courts are doing their best to protect Indian Children today - it's just not happening.
The amount of urban Indians who are enrolled or not is part of the problem and a real issue here.
Here is a case from Michigan where the mother said her children were Delaware and entitled to protections under the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978.
Allowing time for tribes to respond is a big issue since many tribes have few or overworked enrollment officers who can't always get historical information to enroll their members and/or their children who live off rez. If tribes did manage enrollment at birth, it would certainly help.
Convincing me courts are doing their best to protect Indian Children today - it's just not happening.
The amount of urban Indians who are enrolled or not is part of the problem and a real issue here.
Here is a case from Michigan where the mother said her children were Delaware and entitled to protections under the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978.
Allowing time for tribes to respond is a big issue since many tribes have few or overworked enrollment officers who can't always get historical information to enroll their members and/or their children who live off rez. If tribes did manage enrollment at birth, it would certainly help.
Convincing me courts are doing their best to protect Indian Children today - it's just not happening. The amount of urban Indians who are enrolled or not is part of the problem and a real issue here. Here is a case from Michigan where the mother said her children were Delaware and entitled to protections under the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978. Allowing time for tribes to respond is a big issue since many tribes have few or overworked enrollment officers who can't always get historical information to enroll their members and/or their children who live off rez. If tribes did manage enrollment at birth, it would certainly help.
Convincing me courts are doing their best to protect Indian Children today - it's just not happening. The amount of urban Indians who are enrolled or not is part of the problem and a real issue here. Here is a case from Michigan where the mother said her children were Delaware and entitled to protections under the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978. Allowing time for tribes to respond is a big issue since many tribes have few or overworked enrollment officers who can't always get historical information to enroll their members and/or their children who live off rez. If tribes did manage enrollment at birth, it would certainly help.
Convincing me courts are doing their best to protect Indian Children today - it's just not happening. The amount of urban Indians who are enrolled or not is part of the problem and a real issue here. Here is a case from Michigan where the mother said her children were Delaware and entitled to protections under the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978. Allowing time for tribes to respond is a big issue since many tribes have few or overworked enrollment officers who can't always get historical information to enroll their members and/or their children who live off rez. If tribes did manage enrollment at birth, it would certainly help.
Convincing me courts are doing their best to protect Indian Children today - it's just not happening. The amount of urban Indians who are enrolled or not is part of the problem and a real issue here. Here is a case from Michigan where the mother said her children were Delaware and entitled to protections under the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978. Allowing time for tribes to respond is a big issue since many tribes have few or overworked enrollment officers who can't always get historical information to enroll their members and/or their children who live off rez. If tribes did manage enrollment at birth, it would certainly help.
T he Métis National Council and the Government of Canada will be working collaboratively, Nation-to-Nation, to develop a process to engag...
To Veronica Brown
Veronica, we adult adoptees are thinking of you today and every day. We will be here when you need us. Your journey in the adopted life has begun, nothing can revoke that now, the damage cannot be undone. Be courageous, you have what no adoptee before you has had; a strong group of adult adoptees who know your story, who are behind you and will always be so.
OUR HISTORY
BOOK 5: Lost Children of the Indian Adoption Projects