BACK UP BLOG (no longer updating)

This blog was a backup for American Indian Adoptees blog
USE THE SEARCH BAR or SEARCH TOPICS at bottom of this blog

If you need support

Support Info: If you are a Survivor and need emotional support, a national crisis line is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week: Residential School Survivor Support Line: 1-866-925-4419. Additional Health Support Information: Emotional, cultural, and professional support services are also available to Survivors and their families through the Indian Residential Schools Resolution Health Support Program. Services can be accessed on an individual, family, or group basis.” These & regional support phone numbers are found at https://nctr.ca/contact/survivors/ . MY EMAIL: tracelara@pm.me

Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Supreme Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Supreme Court. Show all posts

Thursday, August 1, 2024

The Great Divider: How the Baby Veronica case was the sign

 REBLOG from February 24, 2014

By Trace Hentz

OK, as promised, I have more thoughts after I went to the hallowed halls of Yale Law School last Friday to hear a review of the Baby Veronica Case - and to hear what NCAI, NARF and the Tribal Supreme Court Law Project at Yale were doing while this major case was going on... and I reported to you yesterday what they said essentially…

There weren't any surprises for me unless you count how these panelists didn't use the time to discuss the genocide that actually occurred prior the passing of the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 and the child abductions by social workers and missionaries - nor did they mention human trafficking and the Nightlight Adoption Agency dealings with Maldonado, the birthmother.  They did mention boarding schools.

So, I was truly upset. From what I heard, it appears American Indians are eons behind in civil rights and we can't seem to win a case in the Supreme Court.  I’d heard that warning years prior but this time at Yale was a bit more in my face. This case was about adoption by non-Indians, something I lived myself.

We had Justice Alito writing an opinion that Veronica is 1.2% Indian.  NARF attorney Joel West Williams asked the Yale audience, "Who in America is 1/16 or 3/256th anything?"  Yet we have a judge issuing his opinion by measuring an Indian for their Indian-ness which equates to measuring a child’s blood? This is still happening?

·        JUSTICE ALITO delivered the opinion of the Court:
This case is about a little girl (Baby Girl) who is classified as an Indian because she is 1.2% (3/256) Cherokee. Because Baby Girl is classified in this way, the South Carolina Supreme Court held that certain provisions of the federal Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 required her to be taken, at the age of 27 months, from the only parents she had ever known and handed over to her biological father, who had attempted to relinquish his [**736]parental rights and who had no prior contact with the child. The provisions of the federal statute [*2557] at issue here do not demand this result.


 

·        Jun 25 2013: Judgment REVERSED and case REMANDED. Alito, J., delivered the opinion of the Court, in which Roberts, C. J., and Kennedy, Thomas, and Breyer, JJ., joined. Thomas, J., and Breyer, J., filed concurring opinions. Scalia, J., filed a dissenting opinion. Sotomayor, J., filed a dissenting opinion, in which Ginsburg and Kagan, JJ., joined, and in which Scalia, J., joined in part. Read more here
·         

I couldn’t sleep ... Dusten Brown never had a chance. He went to Iraq knowing the Capobiancos had his daughter but he had to serve a year and a JAG lawyer took his case.  The puzzle remains why Maldonado mysteriously breaks up with him and severs all communication. Was she punishing her high school sweetheart Dusten by selling his baby or was she manipulated by the adoption agency to take their money?

Then it hit me - keeping America ignorant of Indians, culture, actual history - this all works to take Indian children.  Judgment is easy.  Third World poverty (which we didn’t create) somehow equates to abuse of children.  Add their general ignorance of sovereignty and culture, what it means to be Cherokee or Lakota or Navajo or any tribe - and it means you can't win public opinion polls or cases before the Supreme Court? 

Ignorance about Indians? Exactly!

It's been going on since colonial contact.  Please, let's not call them settlers anymore but invaders.  America has always been the Great Divider, building its fences, writing its laws, counting on classism and racism to divide us. 

America wins every time when it perpetuates this ignorance of Indians.  Do Indians do a good job of educating others about culture, or what's important to us?  Not really.  We're way behind in any civil rights movement.  We've had movies romanticizing us over 100 years and it's hard to kill those "savage" “redskin” stereotypes drilled into all our heads!  

What do Americans know about Indians? Nothing.  Practically zilch.

America's "taking care" of Indians only works to create HATE among Americans who view us as privileged in some way that they are not.  Like why do we even have a law that keeps nice white people from adopting Indian babies?  Trust me, ICWA is under attack.

I do know that Indians are way ahead in surviving every broken treaty and then fighting each other over small scraps of power.  Some tribes even subscribe to "blood quantum" as if they need to purge their citizen rolls of those who may be too white or too black.

We have Supreme Court Justices using the blood quantum argument and you see that is not entirely their fault (they all went to law school but didn’t even have a course on Indian Law at those Ivy League schools) but it tells me - do not go anywhere near them.  They are not even aware of their ignorance.  Dusten Brown didn't have a chance, not in that court.

We Indians shouldn't go anywhere near that court or any court with that level of stupidity.  No, you can't tell Americans they are stupid.

What the panel did say was each and every tribe needs to create and have their own child protection network. I agree since it's pretty evident that you can't trust any non-Indian social worker to go to the reservation and use their mother- father “family unit” example.  Only Indians can decide who the right people are to care for its children.  That person might be an auntie, grandmother or another relative, depending on who in the tribal family is willing and able.

And the panel said we need more American Indian lawyers who become judges - because the way it is now - Indians can’t win.

For many years Vine Deloria and others did try very hard to educate others (with their brilliant books) on the white man’s level, even earning degrees in white man’s colleges like Yale and Harvard, but it all comes down to this:  whites don’t really care.

And if we really think about it, this is a very dangerous situation to be in.


Footnote:  I attended white schools like most everyone else - Really nothing I learned was true or real about Indian culture or history. I learned more sitting at the kitchen table of my friend Ellowyn who is Oglala Lakota, who gave me an education about Indians not written about anywhere.  Then there was my one adoptive aunt (a first-born American) who calls me a liar when I told her there were Indian Boarding Schools, and this was right after I visited Haskell in Kansas.  No, Americans are not learning about Indians or the truth of our history. 
The Baby Veronica case is the sign, whether we wish to see it that way or not - but we can no longer ignore the ignorance or the danger surrounding this case. 
 
THIS BLOG HAS MANY POSTS ABOUT THE BABY V CASE... Yes, she was adopted out...
 
BLOODISM? READ THIS

Monday, March 25, 2024

The Great Divider: How the Baby Veronica case was the sign

 REBLOG from February 24, 2014

By Trace Hentz

OK, as promised, I have more thoughts after I went to the hallowed halls of Yale Law School last Friday to hear a review of the Baby Veronica Case - and to hear what NCAI, NARF and the Tribal Supreme Court Law Project at Yale were doing while this major case was going on... and I reported to you yesterday what they said essentially…

There weren't any surprises for me unless you count how these panelists didn't use the time to discuss the genocide that actually occurred prior the passing of the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 and the child abductions by social workers and missionaries - nor did they mention human trafficking and the Nightlight Adoption Agency dealings with Maldonado, the birthmother.  They did mention boarding schools.

So, I was truly upset. From what I heard, it appears American Indians are eons behind in civil rights and we can't seem to win a case in the Supreme Court.  I’d heard that warning years prior but this time at Yale was a bit more in my face. This case was about adoption by non-Indians, something I lived myself.

We had Justice Alito writing an opinion that Veronica is 1.2% Indian.  NARF attorney Joel West Williams asked the Yale audience, "Who in America is 1/16 or 3/256th anything?"  Yet we have a judge issuing his opinion by measuring an Indian for their Indian-ness which equates to measuring a child’s blood? This is still happening?

·        JUSTICE ALITO delivered the opinion of the Court:
This case is about a little girl (Baby Girl) who is classified as an Indian because she is 1.2% (3/256) Cherokee. Because Baby Girl is classified in this way, the South Carolina Supreme Court held that certain provisions of the federal Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 required her to be taken, at the age of 27 months, from the only parents she had ever known and handed over to her biological father, who had attempted to relinquish his [**736]parental rights and who had no prior contact with the child. The provisions of the federal statute [*2557] at issue here do not demand this result.


 

·        Jun 25 2013: Judgment REVERSED and case REMANDED. Alito, J., delivered the opinion of the Court, in which Roberts, C. J., and Kennedy, Thomas, and Breyer, JJ., joined. Thomas, J., and Breyer, J., filed concurring opinions. Scalia, J., filed a dissenting opinion. Sotomayor, J., filed a dissenting opinion, in which Ginsburg and Kagan, JJ., joined, and in which Scalia, J., joined in part. Read more here
·         

I couldn’t sleep ... Dusten Brown never had a chance. He went to Iraq knowing the Capobiancos had his daughter but he had to serve a year and a JAG lawyer took his case.  The puzzle remains why Maldonado mysteriously breaks up with him and severs all communication. Was she punishing her high school sweetheart Dusten by selling his baby or was she manipulated by the adoption agency to take their money?

Then it hit me - keeping America ignorant of Indians, culture, actual history - this all works to take Indian children.  Judgment is easy.  Third World poverty (which we didn’t create) somehow equates to abuse of children.  Add their general ignorance of sovereignty and culture, what it means to be Cherokee or Lakota or Navajo or any tribe - and it means you can't win public opinion polls or cases before the Supreme Court? 

Ignorance about Indians? Exactly!

It's been going on since colonial contact.  Please, let's not call them settlers anymore but invaders.  America has always been the Great Divider, building its fences, writing its laws, counting on classism and racism to divide us. 

America wins every time when it perpetuates this ignorance of Indians.  Do Indians do a good job of educating others about culture, or what's important to us?  Not really.  We're way behind in any civil rights movement.  We've had movies romanticizing us over 100 years and it's hard to kill those "savage" “redskin” stereotypes drilled into all our heads!  

What do Americans know about Indians? Nothing.  Practically zilch.

America's "taking care" of Indians only works to create HATE among Americans who view us as privileged in some way that they are not.  Like why do we even have a law that keeps nice white people from adopting Indian babies?  Trust me, ICWA is under attack.

I do know that Indians are way ahead in surviving every broken treaty and then fighting each other over small scraps of power.  Some tribes even subscribe to "blood quantum" as if they need to purge their citizen rolls of those who may be too white or too black.

We have Supreme Court Justices using the blood quantum argument and you see that is not entirely their fault (they all went to law school but didn’t even have a course on Indian Law at those Ivy League schools) but it tells me - do not go anywhere near them.  They are not even aware of their ignorance.  Dusten Brown didn't have a chance, not in that court.

We Indians shouldn't go anywhere near that court or any court with that level of stupidity.  No, you can't tell Americans they are stupid.

What the panel did say was each and every tribe needs to create and have their own child protection network. I agree since it's pretty evident that you can't trust any non-Indian social worker to go to the reservation and use their mother- father “family unit” example.  Only Indians can decide who the right people are to care for its children.  That person might be an auntie, grandmother or another relative, depending on who in the tribal family is willing and able.

And the panel said we need more American Indian lawyers who become judges - because the way it is now - Indians can’t win.

For many years Vine Deloria and others did try very hard to educate others (with their brilliant books) on the white man’s level, even earning degrees in white man’s colleges like Yale and Harvard, but it all comes down to this:  whites don’t really care.

And if we really think about it, this is a very dangerous situation to be in.


Footnote:  I attended white schools like most everyone else - Really nothing I learned was true or real about Indian culture or history. I learned more sitting at the kitchen table of my friend Ellowyn who is Oglala Lakota, who gave me an education about Indians not written about anywhere.  Then there was my one adoptive aunt (a first-born American) who calls me a liar when I told her there were Indian Boarding Schools, and this was right after I visited Haskell in Kansas.  No, Americans are not learning about Indians or the truth of our history. 
The Baby Veronica case is the sign, whether we wish to see it that way or not - but we can no longer ignore the ignorance or the danger surrounding this case. 
 
THIS BLOG HAS MANY POSTS ABOUT THE BABY V CASE... Yes, she was adopted out...
 
BLOODISM? READ THIS

Thursday, June 15, 2023

Supreme Court affirms ICWA

UPDATED:
‘The bottom line is that we reject all of petitioners’ challenges to
the statute, some on the merits and others for lack of standing’

 

Justice Neal Gorsuch, the justice with extensive federal Indian law
knowledge and experience of all the justices, wrote in support:

"Often,
Native American Tribes have come to this Court seeking justice only to
leave with bowed heads and empty hands. But that is not because this
Court has no justice to offer them. Our Constitution reserves for the
Tribes a place—an enduring place—in the structure of American life. It
promises them sovereignty for as long as they wish to keep it. And it
secures that promise by divesting States of authority over Indian
affairs and by giving the federal government certain significant (but
limited and enumerated) powers aimed at building a lasting peace"

 

READ THIS

Wednesday, April 19, 2023

Part 5: What if We Lost ICWA | Our Sovereignty


The plaintiffs, Brackeens, assert ICWA is an unconstitutional law

PART 5: 
Haaland v. Brackeen

By Trace L Hentz, blog editor and adoptee

Am I worried about the ICWA case? Yes. Very.

I am worried that the "Supreme" Court has shown no respect for our inherent sovereign rights.  Just look at history.  This case could rescind the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978.  I worry the impact on adoptees now and future Native adoptees.  (ICWA allows adoptees to open their adoption records.)  We are called The Stolen Generation and Sixties Scoop for good reason.

We lost our sovereignty when we were adopted out to white families.  We lost everything - language, culture, land, family, ceremonies and our tribal stories.  (Some of us lost our sanity too!)  Swimming pools, college degrees, and white families in fancy houses, cannot replace this.

Sadly, I do not think these Justices actually know what our loss means!

Many years ago in Wisconsin, two tribal chiefs gave talks to new congresspeople on Sovereignty 101- I interviewed them about it and then wrote an article in News from Indian Country.  They explained it used to be feds (the federal government) that dealt with tribes and the feds were keenly aware of sovereign tribal rights and history.  Both chiefs said state lawmakers were not as understanding.  There was also high turn-over in states and many new congressmen don't know state or federal history, even how tribes signed numerous treaties.

The Department of WAR (who authorized killing Indians) morphed eventually into the Department of the Interior.



I looked back at my blog posts: Sovereignty and how it applies to Haaland vs. Brackeen.

As Rebecca Nagle explained: "A host of federal statutes—including on land rights, water rights,
health care, gaming, criminal and civil jurisdiction, and tribal
self-governance—treat Native Americans differently based on this
political classification.  In this light, I fear that the Brackeen lawsuit is the first in a row of dominoes—if the Court strikes down ICWA, everything else could soon go with it."

"Under federal law, tribes and tribal citizens are
not a racial group, but a political one.  Accordingly, ICWA applies only
to Native children who either are enrolled in a federally recognized
tribe or are eligible based on a given tribe’s citizenship requirements," Nagle said. 

And this:

This cultural difference — that a
family’s fitness is determined by its wealth, and that those concerns
should outweigh a child’s connection to their family and heritage — is
essentially why the Indian Child Welfare Act was created in 1978.  The
law recognizes the history of federal policy aimed at breaking up Native
families and mandates that, whenever possible, Native families should
remain together.




Sarah Kastelic, the executive director
of the National Indian Child Welfare Association, said that ICWA
acknowledges important familial and tribal bonds that have long been
disregarded, and that Native ways — such as extended families living
under the same roof — have often been used to show unfitness in child
welfare proceedings. “No matter the picket fences and swimming pools and
things, most of the time, kids want to be with their families,” she
said.




READ: The Native adoption case that could dismantle the Indian Child Welfare Act, explained - Vox


THE INTERIOR AND INDIAN AFFAIRS:


👇This is a bit technical but it is the argument the Justices are deliberating:

"What's Missing in the Brackeen Argument: An Indian Affairs Clause"





|





I was chatting with Prof. Lorianne Updike Toler
(Northern Illinois), and she mentioned some thoughts of hers on this
subject, based on her recent University of Chicago Law Review article, The Missing Indian Affairs Clause. I encouraged her to write up a blog post, and she kindly passed along the following:


In the November 9th oral argument for Haaland v. Brackeen,
which challenges the constitutionality of the Indian Child Welfare Act,
Justice Amy Coney Barret's question about the impact of overruling
Congress' plenary power over tribes underscores a centuries-old
confusion about federal Indian Affairs.


It's not just the Court that is confused.  Former Volokh Conspiracy posts on point
reveal the deep academic fissures over the historical context of the
Indian Commerce Clause.  Unknown to the Court and most of academe is the
root cause of all the confusion: that the Constitutional Convention
initially forgot (and then later intentionally excluded) the Articles of
Confederation's Indian Affairs Clause in the Constitution.



As I detail in this University of Chicago Law Review article,
Pennsylvanian comparative constitutionalist James Wilson, tasked by the
five-member Committee of Detail to draft the Constitution, initially
checked off "Indian Affairs" to include as a Congressional power, but
then failed to get the power into his final draft.  He was not the only
one to forget.  Although the Convention had commissioned the Committee to
include all the Congressional powers in the Articles of
Confederation (where Indian Affairs featured), Edmund Randolph also
forgot to include the power in his initial sketch of the Constitution.  Odd, considering a Cherokee chief had met with him that summer in
Philadelphia and he was then directly concerned with settler-tribe
disputes on Virginia's frontier as the state's governor.  It was John
Rutledge, the South Carolinian chair of the committee, who remembered,
scrawling the power in the margin of Randolph's sketch. Yet he later
forgot this power in combing through Wilson's final draft, and it was
reported out of the Committee sans (without mentioning) Indian Affairs.


But James Madison remembered.  It was he who suggested Indian Affairs
be inserted back into the Constitution.  This time, the Committee of
Detail intentionally excluded the Clause, instead inserting "Tribes"
into the Commerce Clause.  No one objected.  This despite that at least
three Convention members had just spent their ten-day break (for the
Committee of Detail to meet) fulfilling their congressional duties in
New York.  There, impending tribal wars in Virginia and Georgia's Creek
disputes were discussed.  Presumably, the Convention thought Congress'
previous powers under the Article's Indian Affairs were addressed by the
Indian Commerce Clause and other provisions of the Constitution—such as
the power to declare war and peace and the president's shared Treaty
Power.


What does this mean for the Constitution? Put simply, Congress has no
Indian Affairs power, and therefore no plenary power
. Early assertion
of this power was justified under the tripartite powers of Indian
Commerce, War and Treaty Powers. But Congress halted tribal
treaty-making long ago.  If it wants to re-assert power over tribes
beyond the Commerce Clause, the President needs to begin treating with
tribes again.

And what of any residual power? As I propose in my article linked
above, the residue reverts to the sovereign tribes. Tribal sovereignty
is to tribes what federalism is to the states. Powers not reserved by
the Constitution to Congress and the President revert to the tribes.


This would mean that Congress lacked constitutional power to pass
ICWA, however well-intentioned.  ICWA was adopted in an attempt to
prevent Native American erasure
by allowing the community to intervene
in adoption and foster cases to ensure tribal children are raised in
Native American families.  ICWA grants the child's tribe exclusive
jurisdiction over custody proceedings and other intervention privileges.  Further, it establishes placement preferences first in favor of any
family members, then the tribe, and then any Native American families
regardless of tribal membership.


Unless related to its Indian Commerce power (and heaven forbid if we
have arrived at treating adoption of babies and children as commerce
),
Congress has no power over Native American adoptions. On this basis,
ICWA might be unconstitutional wholesale.  However, to the extent ICWA
respects tribal sovereignty and refers cases to the child's tribe, it
may be constitutional under a structural reading of the Constitution:  The combined intratextual references to tribes as the constitutional
unit of recognition— "tribes" under the Commerce Clause and the
presumption that Indians are not taxed under Art I. sec. 2 of the
Constitution—together with the parallel analog of federalism vis-à-vis
states may permit Congress to proactively proscribe federal and state
deference to tribal power.  But as Congress has no plenary power over
tribes and Native Americans as a people, it cannot specify adoption
placement or other preferences.  The Court should so rule in Brackeen.


👇👇👇This gives me hope:

 

read:

Native American Law and Sovereignty Institute, “Expert Q&A:
Professor EagleWoman Explains Important ICWA Case Heading to Supreme
Court,” March 10, 2022, Mitchell Hamline School of Law, n.d., https://mitchellhamline.edu/native-american-law-and-sovereignty/2022/03/10/expert-qa-professor-eaglewoman-explains-important-icwa-case-heading-to-supreme-court/. 

(to be continued)


Wednesday, March 8, 2023

Part 2: What if We Lost ICWA? CULTURAL GENOCIDE


By Trace L. Hentz, Blog Editor and Adoptee (video editor from 2014)


I have been rereading TWO WORLDS: Lost Children of the Indian
Adoption Projects (second edition).  It's first person accounts of adoptions by non-Native parents and our history.

What was life like pre-ICWA?

Can we please look at the impact of closed adoptions through the eyes of the adoptee-adult?  We are called the Stolen Generation, remember that.

The word often used about being adopted is “cultural genocide and culture loss.”

If we lose ICWA, we go back to that earlier form of genocide: Less Indians on the rolls, less people on the rez, and the adoptee will lose years of ancestral
knowledge and history and language we would have received from our
relatives. (There are very few adoptees back on their rez.)

This cultural knowledge is not found in books. It’s learned at a kitchen table,
in the kitchen cooking, hunting or gathering with your parents, at a beading circle, at a memorial/funeral, or at a social gathering like a powwow, on in ceremony.  It’s learned walking the land. It’s learned hearing your grandparents tell stories. It’s learned over years of contact, contact with your people, your clan, your cousins,
your tribal nations.

That knowledge is your inherent sovereign right as a sovereign citizen of your TRIBAL NATION, that lies within the boundaries of America or Canada.

Babies and children adopted by non-Natives, this ancient ancestral knowledge and language is gone, erased. Your tribal history is gone.

YOU ARE GONE.


Do you think the Supreme Court knows anything about this cultural genocide?  Do you think they know about 1,000 Indian Wars? No treaty went unbroken. Do you think it matters to them what happened 100 years ago, or since ICWA was passed in 1978 to stop the adoption industry and the united states funding child trafficking?

Do adoptive parents know about cultural loss? What do they plan to do when the child asks about their tribe, or their parents, or their history, or their language?

“What is my language,” a child might ask. “Where are my people?”

If We Lost ICWA?

Think about Arnold Lyslo who ran the Indian Adoption Projects in America. He was busy selling his story ideas to magazines so white readers would feel sympathy and want to help. He counted his successes in how many Indian children were placed with white families. (Success? Erased: off the rez, off the rolls.)

It was the perfect storm. The adopters were not told there was a massive inter-country genocidal project going on. They just thought: “Hey, were doing a
good thing (adopting a Native kid.)”

How many of these adoptions failed? (I wanted to know that. I asked adoptees to write their stories in the anthologies Two Worlds, Called Home and Stolen
Generations.) I sent a bunch of questions to each adoptee.

How many adoptees committed suicide? We don’t know.

How many adoptees acted out and were sent to prison?  Too many actually, quite a few I heard about.

Nobody wants Indians to have anything – especially good-sized populations – that would not work for the people who make sure “Indians stay poor.”

What happens if ICWA fails, and adoption goes widespread again and there is some new method of closed adoptions, like the earlier INDIAN ADOPTION PROJECT(s), or ARENA?  What if they open new boarding schools and force Indian children to attend?   The governments of Canada and America funded them, gave the churches money to take Indian kids, some literally abducted off the rez at gunpoint?

To be continued 

If you cannot afford to buy the book Two Worlds, please email Trace (tracelara@pm.me)



Thursday, December 8, 2022

One Choinumni man's adoption horror story
















Emerson Gorman (R), who is a Navajo elder, poses at his property with his (L-R) daughter Naiyahnikai, wife Beverly and grandchild Nizhoni near the Navajo Nation town of Steamboat in Arizona on May 23, 2020. - Emerson Gorman knows what it's like to face the destruction of his culture: when he was five-years-old he was among thousands of Navajo children taken from their families and sent to Christian schools that tried to erase their belief systems.



Emerson
Gorman (right) was one of the thousands of Navajo children taken from
their families and sent to Christian schools to erase their beliefs. His
daughter Naiyahnikai, wife Beverly, and grandchild Nizhoni are pictured
(left to right) on his Arizona property May 23, 2020.












“But honoring tribal sovereignty isn’t about discrimination or
race. That’s a fundamental misunderstanding of Indigenous rights,” Ciesemier said in an episode meant to draw attention to what’s at stake for Native children.


















Jaimie Nelson, a Choinumni Yokuts man from Fresno, California, was
once one of those children. He detailed on the podcast abuse he
encountered at the hands of a white family who adopted him. For Nelson,
legal experts, and activists, the Supreme Court challenge is an
outgrowth of an intentional and systematic effort to whitewash Native
Americans.



"I am not a victim of some odd set of circumstances where I lost my
sister and my brother," Nelson said. "It was an intentional act built
around ‘Kill the Indian, Save the Man.’"



Nelson referenced words
uttered in 1892 by racist American Army Capt. Richard Henry Pratt.
He tried, along with the federal government, to strip Native Americans
of their beliefs, cultural histories, and traditions. And though Pratt
made the speech 130 years ago, the sentiment he championed is far from
extinguished.



Nelson said eliminating the very constitutional right that attempts
to protect Native children from such cultural atrocities is “a genocidal act.” And he would know exactly what that feels like, because it was attempted on him. 



Nelson told the ACLU of his adoption:




There’s a lot of muddy water in there. I know that it happened
at a very young age in the late seventies. My biological parents, they
were, my mom was either addicted to drugs, my dad was a pretty bad dude.
But it didn’t mean that they had to take us away from our native
family. Our native family wanted to keep us, but the courts indicated,
essentially that there’s nothing you can do about it. They specifically
told my grandmother that there’s nothing that you can do about it. And
from what I understand, from what I was told, it destroyed her that she
was not able to keep us in the home. I don’t have very many memories of
my of my time in the foster care system or any of the sort of lead up to
the adoption. What I do have, I have physical reminders of my
introduction into the system. I have a tracheotomy scar on my neck and
on my sides from apparently when I was abused
, like immediately after
being taken from my Native family.




Nelson said when he learned of the case that will be before the
Supreme Court, he knew he had to do something "because there cannot be
another Jamie."



"There cannot be another child that is taken away because of some
archaic, just genocidal, bigoted ideas," he said. "It’s unbelievable.
It’s unconscionable to me that we still have to go through these
hurdles, but we do."



Dr. Twyla Baker, president of the Nueta Hidatsa Sahnish College,
tweeted about the case five days before Native American Heritage Month
began today. "The thing I can’t get off my mind—it’s about to be Native
American Heritage Month, as SCOTUS is about to hear a case that has the
potential to knock down the Indian Child Welfare Act," Baker said in the
tweet. "This kind of existential dichotomy pops up way too often for
Native people here."



She later added:




“My bad, actually this didn’t ‘pop up’—it was a situation
crafted, intentionally, over years with much larger implications and
intentions to follow. Superficial acknowledgments of our humanity as
other structures work to dismantle our Native Nationhood is really
pretty standard.”




Stephanie Amiotte, a member of the Oglala Lakota Tribe and legal
director for the ACLU of South Dakota, North Dakota, and Wyoming, said
when the Indian Child Welfare Act was proposed, 25 to 35% of American
Indian children were being raised in adoptive or foster homes or other
institutions.  About 90% of Indigenous children were being raised by
people who were not Indigenous, Amiotte said.



She explained that, historically, the federal government’s position
and policy has been “to remove Indian children from their families in an
attempt to assimilate” them “to white dominant culture.”



“It is something that actually threatens the very existence of future
tribes and Indigenous peoples as a population,” Amiotte said.

Wednesday, November 30, 2022

“For Indian country, it is maybe one of the most important cases that has ever gone before the Supreme Court” | The case that seeks to strike down the Indian Child Welfare Act is about colonialism

 NOVEMBER 5, 2022  THE HILL


Supreme Court’s ‘sleeper’ case is major clash over Native American adoptions











The Supreme Court heard a dispute over a
longstanding federal law that gives preference to Native American
families and tribes over non-Native couples when deciding where to place
Native children in custody proceedings.





Although overshadowed by the court’s more politically charged cases,
legal experts say the dispute could prove hugely consequential for
Native American rights and tribal sovereignty.







“It is a sleeper case,” said Mary Kathryn Nagle, a Native rights attorney who filed an amicus brief in the case. “For Indian country, it is maybe one of the most important cases that has ever gone before the Supreme Court.”





The dispute tees up questions about whether the Indian Child Welfare
Act (ICWA) unlawfully imposes race-based preferences when placing Native
children, and if the law amounts to excessive federal overreach into
state adoption policy.





The case plays out against the uniquely troubling history of
mistreatment suffered by the country’s Indigenous population, including
the once-common practice of separating Native American children from
their families and tribes, which the ICWA was designed to combat.





The Supreme Court looked very different when it last confronted a major ICWA question in
2013 and counted the late Justices Antonin Scalia and Ruth Bader
Ginsburg among its members. Although the court now has a solid 6-3
conservative majority, some court watchers believe the current ICWA case
could produce a split among the court’s conservatives.





The complex dispute to be heard Wednesday began when three white
couples who sought to adopt Indian children sued the federal government
over ICWA. Later, additional plaintiffs including the state of Texas
joined the case, and several Indian tribes intervened to support ICWA.





Texas and the other challengers claim, among other things, that the
law’s provision giving preference to Native American adoptive parents
over non-Native parents violates the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th
Amendment.







“A classic example of so-called ‘benign’ discrimination, ICWA creates
a government-imposed and government-funded discriminatory regime
sorting children, their biological parents, and potential non-Indian
adoptive parents based on race and ancestry,” Texas wrote in court
papers.





“Because this Court has recognized that ‘the way to stop
discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the
basis of race,’ such methods violate equal protection.”





ICWA’s passage arose in response to the frequent separation of Native
children from their families and communities by state child welfare and
private adoption agencies.







According to research conducted around the time
of ICWA’s passage in 1978, around 25 to 35 percent of all Native
children were removed from their families and placed either into foster
homes or with adoptive families or other institutions. Among Indian
children in foster care, roughly 85 percent were in non-Native homes,
according to a 1969 survey of 16 states.





“This law was passed against a very disturbing and tragic history of
the wholesale removal of Indian children from families to assimilate
them into white culture based on prejudice about Indian culture,” said
frequent Supreme Court litigator Lisa Blatt at a recent legal forum.
Blatt argued the 2013 ICWA case on behalf of a non-Native adoptive
couple. 





“It started with the Bureau of Indian Affairs putting all these kids
in horrendous boarding schools, and then it then transitioned to the
‘60s and ‘70s to state custody removal proceedings,” said Blatt, a
partner at the law firm Williams & Connolly.







In practice, ICWA requires that Indian children be placed with
members of their extended family or tribe, or other Native American
families before outside candidates may be considered.





Ben Kappelman, a partner at the law firm Dorsey & Whitney who has
provided pro bono services to a Minnesota Indian tribe in child welfare
proceedings, touted the law as a success.





“ICWA, considered the gold standard in child welfare policy,
establishes priority for caregivers of Native American children whose
parents cannot care for them,” he said.





Supporters of the law say the ugly history that led up to its
enactment underscores the enduring need for protections for Indian
children and families’ culture.





“ICWA is based on a simple idea: When Indian children can stay with
their families and communities, Tribes and children alike are better
off,” the tribes wrote in court papers. “By implementing that simple
idea, ICWA ‘promotes the stability and security of Indian tribes and
families’ and ‘protects the best interests of Indian children.’”





The Justice Department, on behalf of the Biden administration, is arguing in support of ICWA.









The case has the potential to create a split among the court’s
conservatives, some experts say. Blatt, of the firm Williams &
Connolly, noted that Justice Neil Gorsuch, a Trump appointee, has
“consistently ruled” in favor of tribal rights and law.





“I think the assumption is that the United States that’s defending
the law with the support of the tribes, has at least four votes,
assuming they have Gorsuch’s vote,” she said. “And that leaves the
challengers needing to pick up both Justice [Brett] Kavanaugh and
Justice [Amy Coney] Barrett.”





A decision in the cases, Haaland v. Brackeen, is expected by summer 2023.

👇👇👇


When You Take Away the Kids, You Take Away the Future


The case that seeks to strike down the Indian Child Welfare Act is about colonialism, not civil rights.

 LISTEN:

 



CLICK OLDER POSTS (above) to see more news

CLICK OLDER POSTS  (above) to see more news

MEGWETCH THANK YOU

HUGE Thank you for visiting this blog and sharing this with your kin. It's appreciated. Contact Trace anytime! Use the form below.

BOOKSHOP

Please use BOOKSHOP to buy our titles. We will not be posting links to Amazon.

Popular Posts

To Veronica Brown

Veronica, we adult adoptees are thinking of you today and every day. We will be here when you need us. Your journey in the adopted life has begun, nothing can revoke that now, the damage cannot be undone. Be courageous, you have what no adoptee before you has had; a strong group of adult adoptees who know your story, who are behind you and will always be so.

OUR HISTORY

OUR HISTORY
BOOK 5: Lost Children of the Indian Adoption Projects