This blog was a backup for American Indian Adopteesblog
USE THE SEARCH BAR or SEARCH TOPICS at bottom of this blog
If you need support
Support Info: If you are a Survivor and need emotional support, a national crisis line is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week: Residential School Survivor Support Line: 1-866-925-4419. Additional Health Support Information: Emotional, cultural, and professional support services are also available to Survivors and their families through the Indian Residential Schools Resolution Health Support Program. Services can be accessed on an individual, family, or group basis.” These & regional support phone numbers are found at https://nctr.ca/contact/survivors/ .
MY EMAIL: tracelara@pm.me
Search This Blog
Showing posts with label Captain RH Pratt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Captain RH Pratt. Show all posts
If you can take 10 minutes, this animated film (above)
is a good overview of that history. There is so much information to
understand, that this animated film can reinforce some of the details.
If you haven't yet called or written your congressperson to support these two bills, here it is again. PLEASE CONTACT YOUR CONGRESSPERSON AND SENATOR TO
SUPPORT THE TWO BILLS PROPOSED BY SEC.DEB HAALAND TO INVESTIGATE AND
BEGIN TO BRING HEALING TO NATIVE AMERICANS ADVERSELY TRAUMATIZED BY THE
BOARDING SCHOOL ERA.
If you would like to be part of educating the public, please consider hosting our film NATIVE WOMEN AND ALLIES SPEAK: What You Weren't Taught in School
Imprisoned for what exactly, you might ask... Being Indian was enough of a reason... TLH
Contested Native Artworks Resurface at Art Fair, Drawing Scrutiny
The drawings, taken from ledger books made by Native people
imprisoned in the 19th century, were sold at auction in 2022 against
tribal members’ wishes.
“Cheyennes Chasing Antelope” at the Donald Ellis Gallery booth at Expo Chicago 2024, from A complete Fort Marion drawing book
(1876) illustrated by Bear’s Heart (Nockkoist, Tsis tsis’tas) and
Ohet-Toint (Ohettoint / High Forehead) (Bonhams lot 20) (all images used
with permission)
Earlier this year, David Nolan Gallery in New York mounted the exhibition Fort Marion and Beyond: Native American Ledger Drawings, 1865–1900,
gathering over 100 works on paper by Native artists from the Arapaho,
Cheyenne, Hidatsa, Kiowa, and Lakota tribes. Co-organized with Donald
Ellis Gallery, the show prominently featured works by Nokkoist (Bear’s
Heart) of the Cheyenne Nation and Ohettoint of the Kiowa Tribe, two of
72 Indigenous warriors who were imprisoned without trial at Fort Marion
in Florida between 1875 and 1878 after the Red River War. The United
States military campaign “aimed at the forced displacement and migration
of Southern Plains tribes onto reservations,” according to a press
release. Art critics called the show “plaintive, pathos-filled” and “heartbreaking,” and Hyperallergic’s John Yau remarked that “the drawings of Nokkoist and Ohettoit … belong in an art museum.”
What was not mentioned, by either the galleries or critics, is that
the exhibition featured several drawings from ledger books that were auctioned off by Bonhams in Los Angeles in 2022. Representatives for the Kiowa and Cheyenne and Arapaho Tribes attempted
unsuccessfully to halt the sale, based on the arguments that the ledger
books represented “significant cultural patrimony” and were created by
incarcerated artists, calling into question the “chain of custody of the
objects,” as Chairman of the Kiowa Tribe Lawrence SpottedBird wrote in a
letter to Bonhams.
The auction house did not disclose the identities of the buyer or
buyers of the four books, which sold for a total of $908,700 including
premiums. However, drawings by Nokkoist and Ohettoint were taken from
three of the books — which had been unbound, and the artworks
individually framed — and included in the Fort Marion and Beyond exhibition.
This past weekend, they were also featured in the Expo Chicago booth of dealer Donald Ellis, who confirmed to Hyperallergic that he was the buyer of those three books at Bonhams in 2022.
Donald Ellis Gallery booth at Expo Chicago this weekend
Members of the Kiowa and Cheyenne and Arapaho Tribes, as well as
other Native individuals with knowledge of ledger drawings, reacted with
alarm and frustration when they learned of the recent displays.
“When I read your email, my heart dropped,” Shannon O’Loughlin (Choctaw), the CEO of the Association on American Indian Affairs, told Hyperallergic.
“It provides another level of evidence of how people are taking control
of our cultural heritage, working to create their own narrative that is
separate from the Native peoples who should be the true holders of this
type of cultural heritage.”
“It just feels wrong that they’re here,” Debra Yepa-Pappan (Jemez
Pueblo/Korean), co-founder and director of exhibitions and programs at
the Center for Native Futures, a Chicago-based Native arts nonprofit that also had a booth at Expo.
Top:
“showing three distinctly attired warriors on hoseback”; bottom:
“depicting a procession of warriors wearing fur turbans and other
distinctive headdresses, a flag bearer at the head of the group,” from A complete Fort Marion drawing book (1876), illustrated by Ohet-Toint / Ohettoint (Bonhams lot 23)
Yepa-Pappan and her colleagues confronted Ellis at his booth, asking
him where the ledger drawings came from and whether any Native groups or
descendants of the artists were benefitting from the sales of the works
the gallery was offering at the fair, which she says were priced
between $8,000 and $80,000. She described his reaction as “defensive”
and “rude.”
On Saturday, April 13, Casey Brown (Ho-Chunk), an artist and member
of the Center for Native Futures, wrote an email to Expo Chicago staff,
raising concerns about the ethics of selling ledger drawings at the
fair.
“I was surprised to see ledger art outside of a tribal cultural
center, museum or archive and also available for purchase,” his letter
read. “This art was made under duress while these men were unjustly
imprisoned; ownership of any of these works is problematic.”
When members of the Center approached Ellis and his assistant, they
were “unable to explain where the collection came from and unwilling to
let them copy down the names of who created these pieces for further
study,” Brown said. “When asked if he had contacted any family of the
unjustly imprisoned men, Ellis said he has ‘strong relations’ with
‘plains tribes’ but openly said he’s the only person profiting from
these pieces.”
Within half an hour of sending the email, Brown was contacted by Tony
Karman, the president and director of Expo Chicago, who spoke with
members of the Center about their concerns.
“We are grateful to the Center for Native Futures for drawing our
attention to the Ledger Books and to Donald Ellis Gallery for
participating in a conversation with the Center around the complex
issues involved,” a spokesperson for the fair told Hyperallergic.
“Expo Chicago has committed to engaging with the appropriate
organizations on the development of guidelines on the display of these
types of materials, affirming our commitment to the proper handling of
cultural property.”
“Sun Dance” from A complete Fort Marion drawing book (1876), illustrated by Bear’s Heart (Nock-ko-ist, Tsis tsis’tas (Bonhams lot 22)
Max Bear, the tribal historic preservation officer of the Cheyenne and Arapaho Tribes, echoed the Center’s dismay.
“When the books were sold, they became art pieces in Pratt’s narrative, not ours,” he told Hyperallergic,
referring to Richard Henry Pratt, the Army officer who oversaw the
prison at Fort Marion. Pratt commissioned and purchased many of the
ledger books — which included depictions of battle, the warriors’
journey as detainees from the Plains to Florida, and prison life —
directly from the incarcerated artists, considering them examples that
his attempts to assimilate and “civilize” Native Americans were
successful.
Bear bristled at the term “ledger art,” adding: “These are historical
accounts from our people, and should be kept by our people.”
Although there has been a growing movement over the past several
years towards repatriation of objects, art, and artifacts to Native
Peoples, the ledger books reside in a legal gray area, said Ross Frank, a
professor in the Department of Ethnic Studies at the University of
California San Diego (UCSD).
“In the letter of law, as it stands now, it’s a hard row to ask all
ledger material to go back to the tribes. It is a kind of cultural
patrimony, but in these cases, there was some kind of sale, which was
legal at the time,” Frank told Hyperallergic. But the works’
legal status aside, Frank noted, “there may be ethical concerns about
coercion” because the artists were imprisoned.
Frank explained that there are seemingly two systems that apply to US
cultural institutions on the one hand, and private dealers on the
other. Institutions should adhere to best practices, involving
consulting with tribes regarding the exhibition and responsible
stewardship of objects related to their culture.
“Recounting
a meeting between two warriors on horseback carrying eagle feather fan
tails, likely representing Tsis tsis’tas (Cheyenne) and Chaticks Si
Chaticks (Pawnee) leaders,” from A complete Fort Marion drawing book, illustrated by Bear’s Heart (Nock-ko-ist, Tsis tsis’tas) (Bonhams lot 22)
The tribal historic preservation officers of the Kiowa and Cheyenne and Arapaho Tribes told Hyperallergic that they had not been contacted by either gallery prior to the exhibition.
According to Ellis, he was approached by “an intermediary on behalf
of the Kiowa” after the auction and offered them the ledger book with
drawings by Ohettoint at his cost (it was sold for $138,975 with premium),
but received no response. He added that his gallery is “supporting
financially and with loans” an upcoming exhibition on Fort Marion which
“dozens of direct descendants of the Cheyenne prisoners” are involved
with.
“They are aware of my activities and involvement in the exhibition and we are not aware of any pushback,” Ellis said.
But as Frank of UCSD explained, “with private collectors, it’s a
whole different world. We’re at the mercy of a global capitalist
system…which values the pages separately far more than the book staying
together,” he said about the decision to unbind the books and display
the drawings separately. (Frank is the founder of the Plains Indian Ledger Art (PILA) project, which digitizes complete ledger books, making them accessible online.)
Ellis defended the choice to detach the drawings, arguing that “one
of the unique aspects of the Fort Marion sketchbooks is that there is no
narrative arch between individual sheets, linear or otherwise, unlike
most books that predate them.”
Karen Kramer, the curator of Native American and Oceanic Art and
Culture at the Peabody Essex Museum, offered a counter perspective,
telling Hyperallergic that “to separate these drawings is to dismantle cultural heritage.”
“Breaking apart ledger books that have Plains Indian drawings
short-changes the possibility of understanding each drawing as a part of
a whole story,” Kramer said. “In the context of Fort Marion, these
prisoner-warrior artists conveyed personal experiences and remembrances
of tribal rituals and histories within the broader story of colonization
and ledger art production under imprisonment and its radical aesthetic
evolution between 1875–78.”
“Depicting
a group of men around a campfire on a wooded beach, likely Fort Marion
prisoners on an excursion to Anastasia Island,” from A complete Fort Marion drawing book, illustrated by Bear’s Heart (Nock-ko-ist, Tsis tsis’tas) (Bonhams lot 22)
It is also worth noting that at least two drawings that were
originally two-page spreads in the ledger books were framed and
exhibited as single sheets, splitting the original image in half, at
Ellis’s Expo Chicago booth.
In his communications with Hyperallergic, however, Ellis made clear that he considers himself more as a caretaker than a dismantler of Native cultural heritage.
“With the possible exception of Ross Frank and PILA, my gallery was
most instrumental in the preservation of complete ledger books over a
20-25 year period before the advent of digitization,” he said. “The
decision to exhibit the drawings as individual works (our first
experience in doing so) was a long and difficult process. Ultimately we
decided the end justified the means.” That end aim, according to Ellis,
is “to bring them to widespread institutional and private attention.” He
noted that PILA has complete files of the three books he purchased and
that he plans to produce facsimile versions.
Institutions that receive federal funding are bound by the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA),
a 1990 law which facilitates the “protection and return of Native
American human remains, funerary objects, sacred objects, and objects of
cultural patrimony.” Private sales are not subject to NAGPRA, but they
do fall under the recently passed Safeguard Tribal Objects of Patrimony (STOP)
Act, which helps prevent international trafficking of objects of
significant cultural patrimony, although that legislation would likely
not apply in this case.
Despite the technical legality of the books’ ownership, O’Loughlin
sees the original terms of the sales by the incarcerated Native artists
to Pratt as reason to reconsider grounds for repatriation.
“If the original transfer does not hold up, if it was considered a
kind of theft, then every transaction after that would be colored by
that,” O’Loughlin said. She considers the books’ current owners
complicit “because they know all the history, they know how the Tribes
fought the purchase.”
Top:
drawing “titled ‘Kiowas’ in pencil, the name ‘Saul’ written in ink
above one of the figures;” bottom: drawing with “‘Kiowa and Wife’ in
pencil, ‘Saul’ in ink above the horseman,” from A complete Fort Marion drawing book (1876) illustrated by Bear’s Heart (Nockkoist, Tsis tsis’tas) and Ohet-Toint (Ohettoint / High Forehead) (Bonhams lot 20)Top: “Cheyenne Feast”; bottom: drawing inscribed “Medicine Dance (Cheyenne),” from A complete Fort Marion drawing book (1876) illustrated by Bear’s Heart (Nockkoist, Tsis tsis’tas) and Ohet-Toint (Ohettoint / High Forehead) (Bonhams lot 20)
Carlisle published a newspaper for students (Take a look👇)
Send THE OSAGE a plague of small pox? (Murder them?)
from the pdf:
PRATT WRITES: Against
the wishes of professional Indian philanthropists (?) who demanded she return to
and help her people, we urged her and she stayed in (PA) to practice her (Nursing) profession.
She has never been without employment,
has fifteen dollars per week and sometimes twenty-five, has helped her family
not a little, and has a bank account of several hundred dollars. This is disintegration of the tribes actually begun.Shall we for any reason whatsoever, remand her
to the base destructive influences of her tribe, to be swallowed up and lost? We have scores of similar cases, and might
have had hundreds and even thousands but for the false principle of always
pouring back into the tribe (leaving his prison school).
We have saddled the
poor Indian the destroying influences of a great pension system and the most
serious work that confronts us in our efforts to make a self-supporting man of
him is the curtailing and elimination of that system. The Osages have $9,000,000 (million) in the
United States Treasury, the interest of which at 5 percent is distributed among
them semi-annually. They occupy a domain fifty miles square, some of it the
best lands in the west. They do not work
because they need not. They spend their
time in debauchery and depravity, encouraged by the surrounding white
influences. Twenty-five years ago they numbered 3490; fifteen years later,
2206; and today they number a bare 1500. Query: Would not the introduction of smallpox at once be
a more humane method of ending the Osage problem. ____ (anyone see the movie "Killers of the Flower Moon"?)
Under their
recent treaty, the Chippewas of Minnesota are expecting to have ultimately from
$30,000,000 to $50,000,000 in the Treasury at interest. They now number over 6500. Twenty years ago, like
the Osages, and from the same causes, they will be reduced one half. Could the ingenuity of Satan devise a greater
evil under a semblance of good? Good
bye, Chippewas!
Experience shows
that Indians massed on reservations can absorb all the educational, religious
and other help given them there and not develop one tittle of a disposition to
become individually independent and citizens.
It is hard to
sidetrack a lie when it goes well started from a high source considered
responsible. Last year it was frequently asserted by a prominent Member in
Congress that Indian children were practically kidnapped and sent to Carlisle and
other Eastern schools by force. Not being
on the floor of the House to contradict it, we contradicted it in a Washington
paper, while Congress was yet in session. This year the same person reiterated the
statement. Two days afterwards, we got
the Congressional Record and saw it. We
then telegraphed to a member of Congress as follows: “ Of the2300 children received into
this school during its 13 years, not one, except 112 Apache youth from the
prisoners in Florida, came here under any other constraint than that of kind
and proper argument, and neither M r. ------- nor anyone else either out of or
in the Indian Service can establish the contrary; whereas there is not a day school
or a boarding school on the great Sioux reservation nor on many of the other reservations,
which do not have Indian police regularly on duty chasing down and enforcing
attendance of students, and to compel attendance at which schools the Agent
does not often deny rations and resort to the same forces, Mr. -------- misalleges
are used to fill eastern schools.
Congress is
being greatly misinformed in this matter.”Our telegram did not reach the gentleman until after the bill had gone
beyond where he could answer. But why
make such statements, as though a great wrong was being done, when Congress has
made legal provision for enforcing attendance by withholding rations and other supplies from whole
families who will not send their children to the schools.
The Indian is a
man, capable in all respects as we are. His
development is governed absolutely by his environment.
Savagery
naturally enforces savagery, civilization enforces civilization. Surrounded by civilization, it is impossible
for him to remain a savage; surrounded by savagery it is almost impossible for
him to either become or remain civilized.
Why then keep up
the farce of feeding our civilization to the Indians?
It is more than
folly and worse than ridiculous to constantly declare (war) against reservations and
tribal influences and to be at the same time always and almost universally
doing only those things which compact the tribe and strengthen the reservation.
At the annual
convention of Methodist church in Chicago to consider the subject of education
and church work the Rev. J. C. Hartzell, general educational agent of the
church in the south, advocated the abolition of the color line both in church
and school. Here is
progress.
From the
standpoint of the Eastern philanthropists (Lake Mohonk) (rich white industrialists) there is but one side
to the Indian question; while, in reality the problem has as many phases as
there are tribes. A statement regarding
one of the thirty-two tribes in the Indian Territory does not necessarily apply
to another.
When the Cherokee Commission
reported that “ the Pawnees defer to the judgement of their educated and
English-speaking young men,” the fact had a special significance. Of the twenty-four tribes visited by the
commission, the Pawnees alone would listen to or be guided by the counsels of
their young men. - (Edward F. Watrous, in Christian Register.)
The young men of
the Pawnees have largely attended schools away from the tribe, which fact alone
is sufficient reason for the above observation.
T he Métis National Council and the Government of Canada will be working collaboratively, Nation-to-Nation, to develop a process to engag...
To Veronica Brown
Veronica, we adult adoptees are thinking of you today and every day. We will be here when you need us. Your journey in the adopted life has begun, nothing can revoke that now, the damage cannot be undone. Be courageous, you have what no adoptee before you has had; a strong group of adult adoptees who know your story, who are behind you and will always be so.
OUR HISTORY
BOOK 5: Lost Children of the Indian Adoption Projects