This blog was a backup for American Indian Adopteesblog
USE THE SEARCH BAR or SEARCH TOPICS at bottom of this blog
If you need support
Support Info: If you are a Survivor and need emotional support, a national crisis line is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week: Residential School Survivor Support Line: 1-866-925-4419. Additional Health Support Information: Emotional, cultural, and professional support services are also available to Survivors and their families through the Indian Residential Schools Resolution Health Support Program. Services can be accessed on an individual, family, or group basis.” These & regional support phone numbers are found at https://nctr.ca/contact/survivors/ .
MY EMAIL: tracelara@pm.me
The
Tlingit & Haida Indian Tribes of Alaska (Tlingit & Haida) and
Washington’s Department of Children, Youth and Families have signed an
agreement on how to provide support services to the Tribe’s enrolled
members — the first formal partnership between that department and an
out-of-state Native nation.
Around 23%, or 1,600, Tlingit & Haida tribal children and youth
under 18 live in Washington state. This agreement specifies roles and
responsibilities shared by the tribes and the Department of Children,
Youth and Families to administer services under the Indian Child Welfare Act,
including child protective services, foster care, dependency
guardianship, termination of parental rights and adoption proceedings
for those children. The department has similar agreements with a number
of tribes based in Washington.
In November 2023, the Tlingit & Haida opened an office in Lynnwood with
at least 20 staff members to serve more than 8,000 tribal citizens who
live in Washington, according to Alaska television station KTOO. These
services include tribal court, enrollment and case management of child
welfare cases.
Native American children in California’s foster care system are
frequently placed in non-relative, non-native homes. Although the U.S.
Supreme Court upheld the 1978 Indian Child Welfare Act, ensuring child
welfare agencies investigate ancestry, contested cases still emerge. This story explores the long-standing issues and the ongoing fight to
protect Native foster care rights in California. Read the full story.
Earlier today, Governor Kathy Hochul
convened leaders from the Indigenous Nations across New York State for a
historic summit at the New York State Capitol in Albany.
PHOTOS of the event are available on the Governor's Flickr page.
Today's summit was attended by the
following Indigenous Nations:
Cayuga Nation
Oneida Nation
Onondaga Nation
Tonawanda Band of Seneca
Tuscarora Nation
Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe
Shinnecock Nation
Unkechaug Nation
This summit follows Governor
Hochul's commitment to supporting and strengthening relationships with
Indigenous peoples across the state. As part of this commitment, Governor
Hochul has:
Appointed the First Deputy Secretary for Indigenous
Nations. Elizabeth Rule was appointed
Deputy Secretary for Indigenous Nations. Elizabeth is an enrolled citizen
of the Chickasaw Nation and an Assistant Professor specializing in Native
American Studies at American University. Prior to joining American
University, Elizabeth directed George Washington University's Center for
Indigenous Politics and Policy. She received her bachelor's degree from
Yale University, and her master's degree and Ph.D. from Brown University.
Visited the Onondaga Nation Longhouse. Governor Kathy Hochul made a historic visit to the Onondaga Longhouse – the first visit by a
sitting Governor in more than half a century – for a conversation with
Onondaga Nation leaders, including Tadodaho Sid Hill, representatives of
the Council of Chiefs, and Clan Mothers.
Returned more than 1,000 Acres of Land to the Onondaga
Nation. Governor Kathy Hochul, joined
by United States Department of Interior Secretary Deb Haaland and Onondaga
Nation Tadodaho Sidney Hill, announced a historic agreement as part of the
Onondaga Lake Natural Resource Damage Assessment and Restoration Program
that will return more than 1,000 acres of scenic land
to the Nation. As Natural Resource Trustees
for the settlement with Honeywell International, Inc., the New York State
Department of Environmental Conservation and the Department of the
Interior's Fish and Wildlife Service signed a resolution that directs
Honeywell to transfer the title to more than 1,000 acres of open space in
Central New York's Tully Valley to the Onondaga Nation - one of the
largest returns of land by any state to an Indigenous nation.
Proposed to Strengthen Stability of Indigenous
Families.The 1978 Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) is a
federal law created to protect the best interests of Native American
children involved in child custody proceedings. The law emerged as
a response to the disproportionate rates at which both residential
boarding schools and state actors removed Native American children from
their homes, communities, and Indigenous Nations. This year, New York’s
Deputy Secretary for Indigenous Nations and the Office of Children and
Family Services, will advance, in consultation with Nation leadership and
stakeholders, strategies to strengthen the objectives of the Indian Child
Welfare Act, underscoring New York’s commitment to redressing injustices
inflicted upon Indigenous communities.
Ensured Dental Care Access for Indigenous Nations. As part of the FY 2025 Budget, New York State will
include $2.5 million in funding for Indigenous
Nations dental health care,
with the aim of addressing gaps in access. This funding will help ensure
Indigenous Nations dental offices and providers can offer treatment without
referring patients off-site and away from Nation territories. This builds
on Governor Hochul’s commitments to lifting up Indigenous Nations
throughout New York, including directing New York’s Deputy Secretary for
Indigenous Nations and the Office of Children and Family Services to
advance strategies to strengthen the objectives of the Indian Child
Welfare Act and commencing a comprehensive review of artistic
representation of Indigenous peoples at the New York State Capitol.
Responded to Offensive Representations. To ensure that all New Yorkers are welcomed in the
State Capitol, Governor Hochul will commence a comprehensive review of
artistic representation of Indigenous peoples in the Capitol, with invited
participation from representatives from each of the nine Indigenous
Nations. All New Yorkers should feel welcome and respected when visiting
the Capitol, but unfortunately, offensive imagery and distasteful
representations of populations in the art which adorns the Capitol can
alienate visitors. Assessments of offensive artistic representations of
Indigenous peoples are informed by precedent more than eighty years old,
and Indigenous peoples, in particular, are often depicted in artworks in a
manner that reflects harmful racial stereotypes and glorifies violence
against Indigenous peoples. Such depictions do not reflect the values of
New York State.
FIRST UP: The New York Times headline June 5, 2019:
Who Can Adopt a Native American Child? A Texas Couple vs. 573 Tribes Here
I posted my comment which became a NYT Pick:
I am an adoptee and journalist who has documented the history and narratives of Native adoptees in three Lost Children anthologies. If the Brackeens had done any research prior, they would know the outcomes for Native adoptees are not good. Adoption gets pretty ugly when it doesn't work. Once kids are out of diapers, they start noticing and feel the isolation without kin. There are medical terms for our damage. The adoption industry will not advertise that most patients in psychiatric care are adoptees. They don’t warn adoptive parents their new child will suffer from “Severe Narcissistic Injury” or “Reactive Attachment Disorder.” This news would not be welcome. LINK
Of course some readers slam me for using the word "kin" ...or ask how do I know about the damage we suffer... No shock... I get it: they don't get it and they don't know the history or the Native adoptees I know personally... (There were 775 comments before they shut it off today and many are amazingly correct!)
An earlier comment from Ellen gets it:
This country has a long brutal history of removing Native children from their families with the intent of culture genocide. There is nothing different about this case. I am sure that the Brackeens are lovely (wealthy) people who care for Zachary, and the new baby they selfishly wrested from her family. Still, it does not undo the damage done to the Navajo nation, in losing 2 precious children, not to mention the damage done to the children in growing up apart from their culture...while being quite different in appearance from the rest of this family. But skin color is not the issue - the erasure of culture and sense of self is.
After reading the NYT story I am not surprised that the Navajo tribe and the Brackeens will share custody, as Judge Kim declared, but the Brackeens would have primary possession. Taking Indian children off the rez and changing their identity to white and ending their sovereignty and treaty rights and a connection to tribal lands: the old playbook is the new playbook. It is always about possession.
We have covered this case on this blog (AMERICAN INDIAN ADOPTEES) for the past few years. (please look at Goldwater Institute (34+ posts) for more insight on this case.)
Hundreds of tribal nations vehemently oppose the lawsuit Brackeen v. Bernhardt that splits Texas, Indiana, Louisiana and a coalition of conservative legal groups, including the Goldwater Institute, against the federal government, hundreds of tribal nations, 21 state attorneys general, Native American civil rights groups and child welfare organizations, including the Annie E. Casey Foundation and the Children’s Defense Fund.
The Navajo are appealing Judge Kim’s custody order.
What about the BRACKEENS?
Potential Adoptive Parents (PAPS) Chad and Jennifer Brackeen might want to learn Navajo history during this lengthy court battle in Texas. (Try this one in 2011: Illegal aliens? Deported adoptees?)
The total population of the Navajo people residing in their land is approximately 180,462 having a median age of 24 years old. Navajo Nation is situated over a 27,000 square miles of large land within the vicinity of the state of Arizona, Utah and New Mexico. It is considered to be the largest land that is primarily covered by the jurisdiction of the Native American within the territory of the United States.
What most people don't know: The Navajo are survivors of a barely-known Mormon assimilation program from 1947 to the mid-1990s.
Year after year, missionaries of the Church of Jesus-Christ of Latter-day Saints approached Navajo families and invited children into Mormon foster homes. As part of the Mormon Indian Student Placement Program, children would live with Mormon families during the school year to “provide educational, spiritual, social, and cultural opportunities in non-Indian community life,” according to the Church.
Typically, the Mormon foster families were white and financially stable. Native American children who weren’t already Mormon were baptized. Although the LDS Church reached out to dozens of Indian tribes, most participants’ families lived within the Navajo Nation.
Roughly 50,000 children participated in the Mormon Indian Student Placement Program, according to Matthew Garrett, a professor at Bakersfield College.
Rather than improving conditions on the Navajo reservation, the LDS Church asked that children assimilate to the way its white members lived. Some Church leaders interpreted the Book of Mormon literally and expected that Native American children’s skin would turn lighter as they grew closer to God.
The Church now admits that not all Native Americans are descendants of the Israelites, or Lamanites, as described in the Book of Mormon. (Oh really, thanks)
In addition to the claims of damage done by sexual abuse, the lawsuits involving the Indian Student Placement Program assert that the culture of the Navajo Nation was “irreparably harmed” by the LDS Church’s “continuous and systematic assimilation efforts.” Although the last student in the Indian Student Placement Program graduated in 2000, plaintiffs are asking the Church to do all it can to enhance and restore Navajo culture and create a taskforce for that purpose. SOURCE: Why Several Native Americans Are Suing the Mormon Church
Participants in the Mormon Church-sponsored Indian Student Placement Program have filed at least three sexual-abuse lawsuits. Lilly Fowler
***
Practices of adopting Native American children directly followed the residential/ boarding schools. Such adoption practices, which came into fruition through forms such as the forced removal of Native American children during Canada’s 60s Scoop and its parallel in the United States, the Indian Adoption Projects, exemplify the adaption of adoption as a settler colonial tool for dispossession and disenfranchisement.
***
Narragansett author John C Hopkins wrote about his Navajo mother in law on his blog:
Chilocco Indian School opened in 1884 with 123 students. Its first graduating class was comprised of six boys and nine girls. The school finally closed its doors in 1980. The name Chilooco comes from the Choctaw word “chiluki” and the Cherokee word “tsalagi,” which means “cave people” in both languages. A long, hard-used tarred road turns off Route 166 and ends where the abandoned, ivy-covered stone buildings stand in disrepair haunted by the ghosts from memories past.
Bernice Austin-Begay, a Navajo, recalled the long ride down the road when she was a child returning to school after a rare family visit. “I’d be sad because I knew it would be a long before I would see them again,” Austin-Begay, Class of 1965, said. “I’d be thinking about my family, thinking about my sheep.” Austin-Begay was 10 when she was first taken to Chilocco. More than 50 years later she still recalls the day the government agents came to Black Mesa, Ariz. and took her away.
“I was captured,” she said.
Many Indian families resented how the government swooped in and took the children away from their families and did all they could to thwart the Bureau of Indian Affairs. Austin-Begay’s family was one of those. Whenever her mother saw a car coming up the road she would send Bernice running, to hide in the hills until the “biliganas” left. (Biligana is the Navajo word for white man) But one day the car arrived unexpectedly and young Bernice never reached the woods.
“I was too slow,” Austin-Begay said.
** 'CATASTROPHIC AND UNFORGIVABLE'
Starting in 1958, the Indian Adoption Project placed Native American children in non-Native homes, in what it said was an effort to assimilate them into mainstream culture and offer them better lives outside impoverished reservations. The project was run by the U.S. Bureau of Indian Affairs, a federal government agency, and the nonprofit Child Welfare League of America, in partnership with private agencies. There was a reason Indian leaders went to the Senate in the 1970s and demanded an inquiry into the staggering number of children disappearing in Indian Country. It was not just boarding schools creating this mass exodus of children. Adoption programs in 16 states removed 85% of Native children. Programs like the Adoption Resource Exchange of North America (ARENA), established by the Child Welfare League of America in 1967, funded in part by the Bureau of Indian Affairs, paid states to remove children and place them with non-Indian adoptive families and religious groups like the Mormon Church.ARENA expanded to include all Canadian and United States adoption agencies and offered them financial assistance.
ICWA (the Indian Child Welfare Act) prioritizes placing Native children into Native homes or with kin or with families that are willing to keep them within a certain proximity to their cultures.
*** Associate Attorney General Tony West Delivers Remarks at the National Indian Child Welfare Association’s 32nd Annual Protecting Our Children Conference ~ Monday, April 14, 2014
"...There's more work to do because every time an Indian child is removed in violation of ICWA, it can mean a loss of all connection with family, with tribe, with culture. And with that loss, studies show, comes an increased risk for mental health challenges, homelessness in later life, and, tragically, suicide."
Adoption Mosaic this Saturday has a great program discussing an alphabet of laws that control many aspects of adoptions, particularly transracial adoptions and adoptions from Native American communities. Featuring Sandy White Hawk, Jordan Davis, Torie DiMartile, Daryle Conquering Bear Crow, and Summer Sullivan, the program discusses the Multi Ethnic Placement Act, Inter Ethnic Placement Act, and the Indian Child Welfare Act and their impact on adoption, communities, and adopted people.
ICWA does more than protect our children from cultural genocide. It safeguards our tribal sovereignty
While most Americans were focused on the 2022-midterm election results, American Indians were searching for clues on how the U.S. Supreme Court might rule in a case that threatens tribes’ very existence. The case, known as Haaland v. Brackeen, was brought by a non-Indian couple (the Brackeens), who adopted two American Indian children. To the casual observer, this case probably looks like state-sanctioned racism in adoption proceedings. You see, the Brackeens claim the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) is discriminatory in granting a preference to American Indians in custody, foster, and adoption cases involving American Indian children. I totally get why anyone unfamiliar with American Indian history and the convoluted legal system that governs tribes’ relationship with the U.S. would scream discrimination.
However, getting to the heart of this case requires some of us to reevaluate what we think we know about the U.S. and its relationship with American Indians. It’s unfortunate that most people know very little about American Indians. It is more troubling that what many do know is based on caricatures promoted by popular culture. Nevertheless, when looking at the Supreme Court’s ICWA case, it’s important to understand that today’s 574 tribal governments existed long before the United States was even conceived. In their dealings with early European settlers, tribes governed themselves and their interactions with others as sovereign nations. In recognition of this fact, the U.S. continues to honor tribal sovereignty through the execution of numerous treaties, the U.S. Constitution, and centuries of federal Indian law. This is the political status that Indian Nations refer to when discussing their relationship with the U.S. government. This political status is also where tribal members derive their rights as citizens of their tribe, the U.S., and the state in which they live. As Justice Kagan noted during oral arguments, “the first thing you need for self-government is, you know, a functioning polity. And Congress is very clear in this statute that it thinks that this statute is critical to the continuing existence of the tribe as a political entity. And that’s, in fact, one of the reasons it passes this statute, is the political entity is itself being threatened because of the way decisions on the placement of children are being made.”
Entering into the world of the child welfare system is, more often than not, a heartbreaking experience. The system is certainly worthy of greater scrutiny and care, but not in the way suggested by the Brackeens’ challenge of ICWA. The Indian Child Welfare Act was passed after Congress spent four years studying the forcible removal of Indian children from their families. During the height of the tragedy, up to 16 times more Indian children were in foster care than non-Indian children. Many of the problems were holdovers of the U.S. government’s abhorrent Indian boarding school policy. To this day, Black and Indigenous people see a higher rate of their children placed in foster care than non-Black and -Indigenous people. In most cases, children are removed because someone has determined they are being neglected. This makes perfect sense. But as University of Pennsylvania professor Dorothy Roberts pointed out on CBS' Sunday Morning, “Neglect is usually confused with poverty. Neglect is defined by most states as parents failing to provide the resources that children need, like clothing or food or secure housing. And those are usually caused because parents simply can’t afford them.”
It is a truly savage system that punishes people whose socioeconomic status is largely the result of decades of discrimination and neglect. Fortunately, Congress recognized the cruelty of the foster care system, as it was applied to American Indians, along with the human rights violations involved in forcibly transferring children of one group to another group. This is why Congress passed the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978.
So, what is this case really about? It’s about commerce. It’s another salvo in the prolonged campaign to weaken and ultimately to end tribal sovereignty. It’s about the perpetual longing of the wealthy and powerful for tribes’ ancestral homelands and especially the resources they contain. For as long as tribes have the ability (albeit limited) to protect their ancestral lands from destructive development and the independence afforded by successful economic ventures, tribal sovereignty will always be seen as an obstacle to this incessant taking. The problem exists because of the United States’ unwillingness to consistently honor its values and promises. The problem is rooted in 1871, when Congress stopped making treaties with tribes and effectively reduced them to domestic dependent nations.
Yet this new status also created a duty on the part of the federal government to protect tribes. It is this duty, as exercised by Congress through its plenary power, that the Brackeen case seeks to exploit. As Justice Gorsuch mentioned during oral arguments, “This new rule would, I think, take a huge bite out of Title 25 of the U.S. Code, which regulates the federal government’s relationship with tribal members.” Gorsuch went on to say, “We’d be busy for the next many years striking things down.” This duty of protection has a spotty record, so many tribes are concerned.
I am concerned, but I am also hopeful. As a U.S. citizen, I’m hopeful that our purported values will prevail. As a tribal citizen, who was orphaned at the age of 12, I know that our tribes are resilient and that our communal values will see that we continue to raise our children in supportive communities, surrounded by the culture and heritage they know best.
Richard Boland is a citizen of the Timbisha Shoshone Tribal Nation and hosted the KNPR podcast Native Nevada.
Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson points to one of 5,703 state flag designs posted in the Utah office in Millcreek, Utah, 2022 | Photo by Carter Williams, KSL.com, St. George News
SALT LAKE CITY — Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson has joined a number of Utah leaders voicing support for the Indian Child Welfare Act and enacting legal protections for Native American adoptions at the state level.
Henderson recently tweeted her support for the act. The law, often referred to as ICWA, was passed in 1978 to safeguard against extensive forced separation of Native children from their families and communities. It is currently being challenged in the Supreme Court.
“A tribe is a political and governmental classification, not a racial one,” Henderson tweeted. “Utah supports the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) and will seek to codify it to protect the eight federally recognized Native American tribes in our state.”
Codifying ICWA in Utah law has widespread support, including from Utah’s eight federally recognized tribes, the Indian Law Section of the Utah State Bar and the Utah Native American Legislative Liaison Committee, which voted unanimously in November to introduce an ICWA bill in the 2023 legislative session. Utah Attorney General Sean Reyes was also a part of a bipartisan coalition that submitted an amicus brief in support of ICWA, arguing that the law fosters good relationships between states and tribal governments.
U.S. Supreme Court's pending decision on a Native American adoption law will impact Mississippi Choctaws. Credit: Courtesy of the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians
A challenge to a decades-old federal law has the potential to impact tribes around the country, including those in Mississippi.
The Indian Child Welfare Act governs child custody of Native children. If a child is removed from their parents, the act sets preferences to place the child with another family member, another member of the tribe or a different tribe.
The case Brackeen v. Halaandbefore the Supreme Court challenges these preferences. Three pairs of non-Native foster parents and three states are suing the federal government and five tribes, arguing the act discriminates against non-Native people based on race.
Tribes including the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians are watching the case and see more at stake than adoption.
“As the only federally recognized tribe in the State of Mississippi, our 11,000 plus members are descendants of those members who chose to remain here in Mississippi to preserve our cultural heritage on our ancestral homelands,” the tribe said in a statement. “Today, just as in the past, the preservation and security of our tribe, and our tribal children and families are of utmost importance.”
“I look forward to taking all of my professional experience and diligently applying it to the work ahead of me,” Maldonado said.
“This is a moment of importance not just for me, but for all of Indian Country as the Governor’s wisdom in this appointment sends a message about the critical importance of the work of tribal courts,” Maldonado added. “I am grateful to the Governor and her team, and I look forward to giving all of Michigan my best.”
I think of greatest importance is Maldonado’s work on the Indian Child Welfare Act. The act was designed to try and keep native children in welfare cases with their family, extended family or a tribal nation. The constitutionality of the law is currently before the U.S. Supreme Court.
As a tribal member she brings a Native sensibility to the state appeals court.
Sierra Charwood, 19, said the possibility of overturning the act is especially scary since her great-grandmother was forced to go to one of the boarding schools the federal government used to forcibly removed American Indian children from their homes in order to assimilate them into white culture. Because of that, Charwood lost the chance to learn more about her language and culture because it was not passed down, she said.
"It directly affected me that way — I don't have access to my language, my history, my roots," she said.
Charwood and other American Indian students fear that if the act were overturned, it could bring back boarding schools.
"Doing this would be taking multiple steps back, and with placing Native children in homes that aren't equipped for them and cannot better them," she said. "If this happens again, we're going to see a big hit to our community."
If ICWA is overturned, it could have ramifications affecting generations of Native children, Littlest Feather said.
T he Métis National Council and the Government of Canada will be working collaboratively, Nation-to-Nation, to develop a process to engag...
To Veronica Brown
Veronica, we adult adoptees are thinking of you today and every day. We will be here when you need us. Your journey in the adopted life has begun, nothing can revoke that now, the damage cannot be undone. Be courageous, you have what no adoptee before you has had; a strong group of adult adoptees who know your story, who are behind you and will always be so.
OUR HISTORY
BOOK 5: Lost Children of the Indian Adoption Projects